Skip Nav
Workouts
The Most Intense 3-Minute Ab Workout
Healthy Recipes
Eat This Valentine's Brunch For an Energizing Romp in the Hay Later
Health News
An Ingredient in Starbucks's New Drinks Might Not Be What You Think It Is

Do Liquid Calories Fill You Up as Much as Solid Calories?

In a time crunch, some of us may head to Jamba Juice for a smoothie lunch substitute. While you are certainly getting plenty of calories in your smoothie, is it filling you up like a solid lunch would?

A recent study says not so much. In fact the subjects who drank their test foods ended up eating more than those who did not drink their foods. Part of the reason could be that drinking your food does not cue signals that let our bodies feel full, such as sight, smell, chewing and pressure of food in the stomach.

I know a lot of you guys follow Slim Fast or will make (or buy) shakes to replace a meal but do you feel just as full as you would if you ate the solid equivalent?

Source

Around The Web

POPSUGAR, the #1 independent media and technology company for women. Where more than 75 million women go for original, inspirational content that feeds their passions and interests.

Join The Conversation
buffyanne buffyanne 8 years
Generally, I would say no; however, I make my own breakfast shakes that are high protien (whey) and fiber (psyllium husk and ground flaxseed) that keep me satisfied for 4-5 hours. For me, that is longer than any kind of cold cereal with milk.
pixelhaze pixelhaze 8 years
I think this was the reason I never liked soups. I dont feel like I've eaten anything.
anners anners 8 years
juices dont, but coffee can curb my appetite for until late afternoon on a work day.
mlmoreno47 mlmoreno47 8 years
The medium sized jamba juice will usually fill me up but it's more of a very high calorie snack. I would never use it to replace a meal.
SWD SWD 8 years
Thick drinks and hot drinks fill me up. Things like soy milk, orange juice, etc, do not. *Great Tip: Add a tablespoon of hemp protein to your milkshake, you cant taste it, and it's healthier for you!
mwmsjuly19 mwmsjuly19 8 years
High protein shakes fill me up like a meal.
intensebandgeek intensebandgeek 8 years
Sometimes, with things like Jamba Juice, I feel full right away. That full feeling goes away pretty quickly, though.
amandaaa amandaaa 8 years
definitely!
fashionhore fashionhore 8 years
Smoothies or coffee will fil me up. If I need to eat something quick and I am driving or running around I get one of those. But I try not to do it too much.
Orchid23 Orchid23 8 years
I love Robeck's smoothies they are very filling, especially the Reg. size, I'll get the jr. size if I'm just craving sweets (much healthier then ice cream) but I usually grab one before my workouts, It gives me the right amount of protein and boost of energy and I burn it off while I'm doing my cardio :)
GeikoSera GeikoSera 8 years
Not at all. I just *inhale* liquids....so I stick to water or tea.
thatgirljj thatgirljj 8 years
There's some variation. Skim milk fills me up more than juice and juice fills me up more than soda. But none of them fill me up the way solid food does.
JBlondie JBlondie 8 years
My rule is not to drink my calories. I would rather eat them!!!!!!!!!
Ashenturtle Ashenturtle 8 years
I end up wanting solid food after my smoothies/liquid calories
wiggle wiggle 8 years
I do think of beer as liquid bread, and do find it really filling. I do NOT use beer as a meal replacement.
kerneschick2005 kerneschick2005 8 years
I have been drinking soy protein shakes mid-morning to replace breakfast and hold me off until a later lunch. They are yummy and easy to make (soy protein, soy milk, frozen fruit, almonds, and cranberries--for texture!)The protein really does the trick for me, it keeps me full.
nikkih nikkih 8 years
Liquid calories don't fill you up like solid calories. I don't think people associate liquids as having as many calories as solids, so they tend to drink and eat, which will only double your intake. So, skip the smoothie and just eat the powerbar (or whatever)!!
rubialala rubialala 8 years
It doesn't seem like it.
angeldevilwings angeldevilwings 8 years
I still crave for solid food after my smoothies.
Evalla Evalla 8 years
Smoothies usually do a good job of filling me up, but I never substitute it for a meal.
Esagashi Esagashi 8 years
If i get a smoothie for a meal, I'll pair it with something like banana or pumpkin bread so that I get the feeling of eating something of substance along with the smoothie- it fills me up and helps me feel as though I haven't left anything out of the meal.
NdHebert NdHebert 8 years
No way. Isnt it gross some people drink shakes while eating their meal? that made me think of it. lol
CamillaCat CamillaCat 8 years
Depending on the drink, it may fill me up as much, but it does not satisfy as long as the solid food would.
eaker eaker 8 years
beer and smoothies fill me up.
Latest Fitness
X