Retro candy lovers, help us decide this Halloween: are Pop Rocks the better throwback, or Pixy Stix? If you're a bigger fan of Pixy Stix, then it's time to weigh in, because they're currently trailing Pop Rocks in the standings for Best Candy of All Time!
From Sugar Babies to Sugar Daddy and Snickers to Milky Way, we've selected 64 of the most beloved candies, and we need your help to pick the winner! Start by clicking above, and go through the first-round matchups by picking your favorite candy each time. Once you've done that, we'll take your favorites and pair them against each other until there is only one winning candy left. At the end of the month, we'll tally up your votes and crown our ultimate candy. Plus, when you finish voting, you'll have the opportunity to enter to win a year's supply of candy from Dylan's Candy Bar. What are you waiting for? Play now!