Skip Nav

Best Candy of All Time Tournament

Will Reese's Pieces Trounce Peanut Butter Cups? Vote in Our Candy Bracket!

Reese's Peanut Butter Cups vs. Reese's Pieces, M&Ms vs. Skittles, Red Vines vs. Twizzlers — it's a battle for the ages in our Best Candy of All Time Bracket. The beloved peanut butter cups are currently in first place, with peanut M&Ms in fourth and Reese's Pieces a distant 16th. So what are you waiting for? Put your money where your mouth is and vote now in our tournament-style competition to settle the sweet score once and for all.

We've selected 64 of the most beloved candies, so start by clicking below, and go through the first-round matchups by picking your favorite candy each time. Once you've done that, we'll take your favorites and pair them against each other until there is only one winning candy left! Just for playing, you'll be entered to win a year's supply of candy from Dylan's Candy Bar. To enter, complete your bracket and enter your email address by midnight PDT on Friday, Oct. 28. We'll reveal the results on Halloween! Click here for official rules. Play the bracket now!

Latest Food
Looking for the perfect gift this holiday season? Order our POPSUGAR Must Have box now >>