POPSUGAR Food Poll At a Birthday Party, Do You Prefer Ice Cream or Cake? by partysugar 9/06/09 0 Shares Like us on Facebook Image Source: Getty Read More Would You RatherIce CreamDessertsCakePollBirthday POPSUGAR, the #1 independent media and technology company for women. Where more than 75 million women go for original, inspirational content that feeds their passions and interests. Get inspired with our daily newsletter Love and Sex Tech DIY Home Food Vegetarian Sign up with By signing up, I agree to the Terms and to receive emails from POPSUGAR. What’s Your Reaction? Thanks for your reaction Don’t forget to share this with your friends! 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Reactions 5 years I love icecream and cake so much.Especially on peoples birthday.its much fun +awsome!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Nyrina-Windu 5 years I like ice cream cake lately. akay 5 years I don't get why anyone likes sponge cake. Soniabonya 5 years I got the Baskin Robbins Ice Cream N Cake song in my head. "do the ice cream n cake! ice cream n cake! x gazillion" Lets see, I love both :) so I picked the option for both. Mmm.. nice scoop of rocky road with a slice of chocolate cake. Yum! But I wouldn't mind Pineapple Upsidedown Cake, Cheesecake (if not homemade, then Costco of Charlie's Cheesecake South San Jose :drool: ), and Carrot Cake. kellylouise 5 years Cheesecake or chocolate cake FTW. But I won't refuse any ice-cream either. I know how you feel ella, I'm starving and yet I'm browsing through yumsugar- that's plain torture. kitkatherine 5 years cupcakes. a totally different world than cake. my fiancee and i have the same birthday and we always end up with 2-3 cakes that no one eats and they are messy and yeah. ella1978 5 years I need to not read the food section until after I've just eaten... cheesecake and icecream cake are awesome & now I'm hungry. Second cup of coffee, here I come!!! mamasitamalita 5 years BROWNIES :) miamixo 5 years Both. I love cake but I don't like ones from a bakery, they taste gross to me. kastarte2 5 years Cake, but I only really want the frosting. :cake: gingirl 5 years Personally, neither. Since my bday is in the fall, I've always loved apple pie with a scoop of vanilla ice cream (or caramel). Oh, love it! Pie always beats out cake. Unless they're cute cupcakes. :) simplyfab87 5 years Cake! Preferably cupcakes or carrot cake. MsTyque 5 years I looove ice cream cake- Carvel with the chocolate crunchies- yum! Also, like Cold Stone, or Baskin and Robbins...ice cream is my weakness :) wunami 5 years I went with both ice cream and cake. But if I had to choose only one, I'd go with ice cream. Partially because regardless if people preferred ice cream or not, there's almost always going to be cake. So it just makes ice cream more enticing since it's less common. 5 years I want chocolate cake with white icing or red velvet cake with vanilla icing or carrot cake with vanilla icing. I want CAKE!!!! :-) shoneyjoe 5 years Martini. marijke 5 years Depends on the cake- I HATE chocolate cake, but plain sponge I could eat every meal, every day, for the rest of my life. No joke. MissSophia 5 years Cheesecake! Preferably French, vanilla, and with warm berry syrup on top. *drool* fashionplate525 5 years Cheesecake! Giasbash6260 5 years How about some ICE CREAM CAKE - OH YEA!!! Sherellj 5 years Cake..Im not a fan of ice cream anymore, well not like I use too. i dont mind a girls night in with ice cream and goodies...mmm Spectra 5 years Cake, but only a really GOOD cake. If it's one of those shortening-frosted supermarket cakes, no way. mcollazo 5 years I would have to go with Ice Cream because I am not a cake eater it is too sweet for me. I can do ice cream cake without the frosting. Although I had cheesecake for my birthday before. That was perfect. sassbidefan89 5 years This might sound really weird but I like carrot cake at bday parties lol GlowingMoon 5 years Cake. I think eat too slow, as ice cream completely melts on me after a few bites.