Skip Nav

Cream Soda Recipe

Off the Bookshelf: Artisan Soda Workshop's Cream Soda

I've never been the biggest soda fan. Even as a child I was far more interested in sugar in solid form (I'm somewhat of a sour gummy candy fanatic) than Coke and the like. Nonetheless, I've always had a soft spot for fragrant cream soda. There's a certain ineffable something about it that manages to lure me in nearly every time I come across it — which is both sadly, and admittedly lucky for my waistline, not that often.

Keep reading for the vanilla-bean-flecked recipe.

Still, and despite owning a much-loved SodaStream, it had never occurred to me to take matters into my own hands and make cream soda at home. Instead I'd turn to the not-too-sweet cream soda offering from Dry Soda when in need of a fix. Yet all it took was a quick flip-through of Andrea Lynn's charming Artisan Soda Workshop cookbook to land on the classic flavor, and suddenly all I could think of was whipping up a bubbly batch. Luckily, this recipe comes with a sweet bonus; while the homemade vanilla bean syrup is perhaps best employed in its original purpose, it can also be swirled into a whole host of beverages, such as coffee, cocktails, or perhaps drizzled atop pancakes. Clearly, I'm looking forward to experimenting.

Cream Soda

Cream Soda

Cream Soda Recipe

Ingredients

1-1/2 vanilla beans
1 cup water
1-1/4 cup granulated sugar
3/4 teaspoon vanilla extract
Sparkling water, either from a SodaStream
or store-bought

Directions

For the syrup:

  1. Carefully slice the vanilla beans in half lengthwise, from tip to tip, and scrape the tiny seeds into a small saucepan, adding the halved vanilla beans as well. Add the water and granulated sugar.
  2. Bring to a simmer, then continue to cook for an additional 3 minutes, or until all of the sugar has dissolved. Remove from heat, add vanilla extract, and allow to cool completely.
  3. Carefully pour it all into a clean jar, including the vanilla beans (they will continue to infuse the syrup), and refrigerate for up to 1 month. To make each glass of cream soda, add 1-1/2 tablespoons vanilla bean syrup to 10 ounces of seltzer water, or to taste.

Makes 1 cup of syrup.

Notes:

  • Once you've used up the syrup, don't discard the vanilla beans; instead allow them to dry out, and try one of these creative uses for leftover vanilla beans.
Latest Food
Award season continues with the SAG Awards! Check out our event coverage!
×