Skip Nav
Taste Test
We Tried the Viral Blue Wine and Here's What Happened
Summer
A Last-Minute Party Dip That Looks Like You Tried Hard
Fast and Easy
Sweet Dreams Are Made of This (6-Ingredient Churro Cheesecake Bars )

Freezing Sorbet

What Went Wrong? Sorbet Too Hard and Icy

Nothing could possibly get close to topping the purity of eating a single, perfectly ripe piece of fruit, but sorbet can get pretty darn close. Since I'm sorbet's number-one fan, and because my last adventure with lemon-buttermilk sorbet went off without a hitch, I decided to try my hand at capturing cantaloupe at its peak.

Unlike ice cream, sorbet doesn't require the finicky step of tempering, so I was certain the method would be more forgiving. Not so much: I modified a recipe from Sunset's One-Block Feast cookbook, subbing honey for honey syrup, then ran it through an ice cream maker as usual. The next-day result? A frozen block of ice that dissipated into granita-like chunks when I tried to scoop it.

Has this happened to you? Any idea what went awry?

Around The Web
Join The Conversation
ViolaMorbid ViolaMorbid 4 years
Too much water content. Next time, just use regular honey. The water turned to ice, which is what made it so hard.
limelindsey limelindsey 4 years
I'm thinking there was too much water as well. I like it that way though! My mom and I used to make lime-ginger sorbet that was to die for, it didn't scoop well but I used to just eat it out of the container with a tiny spoon, shaving off bits as I went along.
Katie-Sweeney Katie-Sweeney 4 years
I'm not positive, but I'm thinking the water content in the honey syrup made the sorbet too watery, so when it froze, it got really icy.
Colleen-Barrett Colleen-Barrett 4 years
Susannah, you need liquor! Just like a tablespoon of vodka or rum or whatever. You don't taste it, but it keeps it from overfreezing.
Popsicle Troubleshooting
Fondue Troubleshooting
What Went Wrong? Sugar Crystallizing in Caramel Sauce
The Difference Between Sorbet, Sherbet, and Sherbert
Blood Orange Margarita Recipe | Video
Raspberry Cabernet Sorbet Recipe
Sorbet With Vodka and Lime Zest

POPSUGAR, the #1 independent media and technology company for women. Where more than 75 million women go for original, inspirational content that feeds their passions and interests.

From Our Partners
Latest Food
X