POPSUGAR Food Poll How Do You Prefer Your Milkshakes? by partysugar 12/01/09 0 Shares Like us on Facebook Sign up for our daily newsletter > Read More Burger BarFrozen TreatsMilkshakesIce CreamDessertsPoll POPSUGAR, the #1 independent media and technology company for women. Where more than 75 million women go for original, inspirational content that feeds their passions and interests. Get inspired with our daily newsletter Tech Love and Sex Vegetarian Food DIY Home Sign up with By signing up, I agree to the Terms and to receive emails from POPSUGAR. What’s Your Reaction? Thanks for your reaction Don’t forget to share this with your friends! 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Reactions sbtroxel 5 years Me and the boyfriend starting making these milkshakes with whole milk a little eggnog lots of cinnamon and vanilla ice cream. Blend it together and its amazing. danakscully64 5 years Thick, Malted, Whipped cream, AND a cherry :) Malts are getting hard to find now and it sucks. Sonic stopped making them and the only place that has them besides a 40's style diner is Dairy Queen. betty-kraker 5 years thick with whipped cream and a cherry suziryder 5 years Malted. And thick! And strawberry! Or vanilla, but I really love strawberry. doogirl 5 years I only exercise in the summer so that I can have thick chocolate milkshakes with whipped cream on top! Heaven!!! fuzzles 5 years Spectra- Oh man. Culver's!!! *looking for car keys* limelindsey 5 years I miss milkshakes. Too much trouble for my tummy, unfortunately. I used to love them when I was a kid, vanilla with fresh grated nutmeg stirred in. Delicious! AmberHoney 5 years Just not a fan. Now gimme a float, that's a whole nother story. Spectra 5 years Very thick. We have this restaurant chain here called Culver's that makes "concrete shakes" that are basically just a cup full of frozen custard that's slightly mixed up and softened. It's to-die-for good, but since they have about a million calories, they're definitely a "sometimes" treat. PopSugarTV 5 years I like it to start out thick and then I love it when it melts and I can sip it like a soda! ChrissyBaby 5 years I love a good thick milkshake. There is a place here in D.C. that serves a toasted marshmallow milkshake that rocks my world. That would have to be my favorite flavor. :-) kea718 5 years Thick, malted, vanilla, with whipped cream and a cherry.... yumm mek123 5 years Strawberry malted with whipped cream (hold the cherry)! mamasitamalita 5 years love black & white shakes :) I worked in an ice cream parlor in high school for a bit and would make shakes with mint chocolate chip ice cream and chocolate syrup too....ohhhh to have my metabolism at 15 again.... Soniabonya 5 years Thick with whipped cream on top. I usually give the cherry to a friend. As for my favorite flavor. . . it's a toss up between classic vanilla and strawberry. Mmm. . . I could go for a shake right now.