Skip Nav
Original Recipes
Make This Oreo Cookie Dough in Just 5 Minutes!
Food Reviews
Updated! Pick Up This, Not That: Trader Joe's New February Foods
Get the Dish
Make Your Own McDonald's Oreo Tiramisu and Experience the Magic

Reese's Oreos Review

Reviewing the New Reese's Oreos

Who hasn't dunked an Oreo in peanut butter or topped fro-yo with both Oreo pieces and Reese's? Yes, Oreos and PB are a dream team, and thankfully, the brand recognizes this. Today, June 9, the latest limited-edition release, Reese's Oreos ($5), will hit store shelves. The classic chocolate wafers are stuffed with half peanut-butter-cup-flavored cream filling and half chocolate-flavored cream filling. It sounds utterly enticing, but did the flavor meet our expectations?

Upon our opening the bag, the cookies gave off a very recognizable Reese's scent. Excited tasters exclaimed "I have wanted this collaboration for years!" and "What a natural fit!"

The first bite reminded us of Girl Scout Peanut Butter Patties (aka Tagalongs). The peanut butter cream tastes reminiscent of Reese's — only sweeter and without the gritty peanut pieces found in the candy. Though we longed for Nabisco to simply fill the Oreos with the Reese's peanut butter, these cookies are still damn delicious. Four- and five-star ratings sprinkled the reviews.


Only one dared to give the cookies a mediocre three stars, claiming the cookies were "too sweet." Some thought the chocolate-cream half was a waste of space. Others wished that Oreos had swirled peanut butter cup pieces into the vanilla cream filling. But most wanted to thank Nabisco for making their peanut butter and Oreo dreams come true. One taster went so far as to say, "I might eat these instead of peanut butter cups." Across the board, tasters would likely purchase a box of these "brilliant" cookies.

Around The Web
Join The Conversation
Starbucks Matcha Pink Drink Review
How to Order a Starbucks Matcha Pink Drink
Oreo Chocolate Taster Job Listing
Wegmans Boycott Over Trump Wine
Best Day to Shop For Deals at Whole Foods
Chinese Restaurant Secrets
Lucky Charms Instant Oatmeal

POPSUGAR, the #1 independent media and technology company for women. Where more than 75 million women go for original, inspirational content that feeds their passions and interests.

From Our Partners
Latest Food
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds