Skip Nav
Fast and Easy
10 Filling Breakfasts You Can Make at Work
Food News
The Cinnamon Roll Doughnut Just One-Upped the Cronut
Food News
Starbucks May Be Opening a Roastery in New York City

Taste Test: Better Oats vs. Quaker Apple Cinnamon Oatmeal

Taste-Off: Apple Cinnamon Oatmeal

My favorite kind of taste test to conduct is a face-off between two like items, whether they're sausage breakfast muffins or fruit and nut milk chocolate bars. So when a kit arrived from Better Oats challenging me to compare its oatmeal to that of Quaker Oats, of course I couldn't pass it up. Our taste-off's surprising conclusion, and other observations, when you keep on reading.

Since both of the oatmeal packets in the taste challenge kit were apple-cinnamon flavored, I was, quite fittingly, able to compare apples to apples. For Quaker's instant oatmeal — the breakfast standard in this country — all I needed was to stir in half a cup of boiling water; a minute later, I was eating a liquidy bowl of oats studded with sprinkles of cinnamon.

Better Oats had less instantaneous results; it called for half a cup of water as well, but needed to be microwaved for two minutes. The finished product couldn't have looked more different: it was darker, dense with grains, and not soupy at all, with visible chunks of apples.

PartySugar and I put our palates to work. Neither of us loved the Better Oats — its consistency was so thick and chewy, I felt a little bit like a horse eating it — but we were shocked to discover how artificial Quaker's apple cinnamon tasted after following it with a bite of Better Oats. In the end, I'll still take a bowl of Irish steel-cut oats over either any day, but if I had to pick, I'd reach for the Better Oats. What's your favorite oatmeal?


Image

Image

Image

Image

Image

Image

Image

Image
Around The Web
Starbucks Valentine's Day Drinks Review
Best Chocolate-Covered Items From Trader Joe's
Filled Cupcake Oreos Review
Pancakes From Scratch
Avocado Toast With Sriracha
What's New at Trader Joe's in February 2016
Quick and Filling Breakfast Recipes

POPSUGAR, the #1 independent media and technology company for women. Where more than 75 million women go for original, inspirational content that feeds their passions and interests.

Join The Conversation
wunami wunami 5 years
Please consider doing taste tests blind in the future.
GummiBears GummiBears 5 years
I live for steel-cut oatmeal. Anything else is just slop in my opinion. True steel-cut oatmeal takes a long time to cook, but I have bought a mini-crock pot and prepare it the night before and in the morning, I have some hearty oats.
Little-Miss-Jay Little-Miss-Jay 5 years
I like quaker oats, but I buy the reduced sugar kind. I also zap it in the microwave for 20 seconds after adding boiling water so it's not a soupy. Quaker apple cinnamon oatmeal with almonds sprinkled on top for protein is my standard breakfast. http://imlittlemissjay.wordpress.com/
katieb82981 katieb82981 5 years
That test seems kind of unfair. I'm not the biggest fan of Quaker Oats, but, if I eat it, I always eat in the microwave, which lets the oats cook a little better.
tigr3bianca tigr3bianca 5 years
I'm not picky about the brand but I use old fashioned oats cooked in soy milk and add in blueberries, cinnamon, and almonds. I think the Better Oats may have needed more liquid when cooking. I find that less processed oats need more liquid and cooking time to become softer.
tigr3bianca tigr3bianca 5 years
I'm not picky about the brand but I use old fashioned oats cooked in soy milk and add in blueberries, cinnamon, and almonds. I think the Better Oats may have needed more liquid when cooking. I find that less processed oats need more liquid and cooking time to become softer.
msdecember msdecember 5 years
believe it or not... i prefer shoprite brand... i have perfected it in the microwave and i add honey, cinnamon, wheat germ, walnuts, and milk. YUM!
Latest Food
X