POPSUGAR Food Thanksgiving What Do You Mix Into Mashed Potatoes? by partysugar 11/19/07 0 Shares Like us on Facebook Sign up for our daily newsletter > Source Read More PotatoesThanksgivingMashed PotatoesPoll Thanksgiving Guess the Secret Creamy Ingredient in This Lightened Up Pumpkin "Cheesecake" Mousse Show Your Appreciation With This 7-Day Gratitude Challenge 25 Reasons You Should Date a Canadian, Eh Burgers and Pasta Salad Have You Overstuffed? Yoga to Ease Digestion POPSUGAR, the #1 independent media and technology company for women. Where more than 75 million women go for original, inspirational content that feeds their passions and interests. Get inspired with our daily newsletter DIY Vegetarian Tech Love and Sex Food Home Sign up with By signing up, I agree to the Terms and to receive emails from POPSUGAR. sf-ragazza 7 years For Thanksgiving, 1/2 & 1/2, white cheddar and sage...yummmm aimeeb 7 years cant eat enough aimeeb 7 years cant eat enough tkoblondee 7 years Milk, butter, sour cream, parsley, salt and pepper, mmmmmmm mmmmmmm good! n_i_k 7 years Ranch dressing mix n_i_k 7 years Ranch dressing mix girllovewarrior 7 years Herbs.Also my special garlic soybutter, it is very nostalgic to me, my mother used to make garlic butter with a baguette to go with soup or salad or something Sunday easy and the way I make it with soy butter is just as good and great with baked or mashed potatoes... healthy too, no cholesterol crap from animal fat butter. girllovewarrior 7 years Herbs. Also my special garlic soybutter, it is very nostalgic to me, my mother used to make garlic butter with a baguette to go with soup or salad or something Sunday easy and the way I make it with soy butter is just as good and great with baked or mashed potatoes... healthy too, no cholesterol crap from animal fat butter. aimeeb 7 years CoronaLove holy calories! aimeeb 7 years CoronaLove holy calories! aimeeb 7 years I can't wait to have some in 2 days!! Advah 7 years Wholegrain mustard! that's the best thing e-ver! kathleenjoy 7 years I chuck in anything I've got on hand ... butter, milk or cream, sour cream, chives, cheese, peas... Schaianne 7 years Garlic and Parsley, usually. pinkgirl22 7 years Sour Cream pinkgirl22 7 years Sour Cream ad2121 7 years little bit of onion powder, salt, and yogurt lms 7 years Wow. I never realized that people put so many different things in mashed potatoes. I like milk, butter, garlic and salt. I sometimes use chicken stock instead of the milk. rothchild 7 years roasted garlic rothchild 7 years roasted garlic michichan 7 years A1 sauce? Holy crow, what a kick. demeter 7 years I make the best baked potatoes ever!!! I mix butter, sour cream, cream cheese, shredded cheese, and sometimes pepper and seasoned salt. I am nowhere near a potato purist! haha aoitenshi 7 years I love mashed potatoes with gravy! ebur47 7 years Rutabagas are awesome with mashed potatoes and butter. k-huffman 7 years For the holidays, I keep in simple with just cream and butter. Homemade gravy and simple mashed potatoes is the perfect combo: no help needed. But when it's just me, I throw whatever I have in.