POPSUGAR Food Thanksgiving What Do You Mix Into Mashed Potatoes? by partysugar 11/19/07 0 Shares Like us on Facebook Source Read More PotatoesThanksgivingMashed PotatoesPoll Thanksgiving Burgers and Pasta Salad Have You Overstuffed? Yoga to Ease Digestion Show Your Appreciation With This 7-Day Gratitude Challenge How to Easily Crimp Pie Crust, in Pictures Protein Balls + Smoothie + Cookies = 1 Can of Pumpkin Get inspired with our daily newsletter Home Love and Sex DIY Food Tech Vegetarian Sign up with By signing up, I agree to the Terms and to receive emails from POPSUGAR. sf-ragazza 7 years For Thanksgiving, 1/2 & 1/2, white cheddar and sage...yummmm aimeeb 7 years cant eat enough aimeeb 7 years cant eat enough tkoblondee 7 years Milk, butter, sour cream, parsley, salt and pepper, mmmmmmm mmmmmmm good! n_i_k 7 years Ranch dressing mix n_i_k 7 years Ranch dressing mix girllovewarrior 7 years Herbs.Also my special garlic soybutter, it is very nostalgic to me, my mother used to make garlic butter with a baguette to go with soup or salad or something Sunday easy and the way I make it with soy butter is just as good and great with baked or mashed potatoes... healthy too, no cholesterol crap from animal fat butter. girllovewarrior 7 years Herbs. Also my special garlic soybutter, it is very nostalgic to me, my mother used to make garlic butter with a baguette to go with soup or salad or something Sunday easy and the way I make it with soy butter is just as good and great with baked or mashed potatoes... healthy too, no cholesterol crap from animal fat butter. aimeeb 7 years CoronaLove holy calories! aimeeb 7 years CoronaLove holy calories! aimeeb 7 years I can't wait to have some in 2 days!! Advah 7 years Wholegrain mustard! that's the best thing e-ver! kathleenjoy 7 years I chuck in anything I've got on hand ... butter, milk or cream, sour cream, chives, cheese, peas... Schaianne 7 years Garlic and Parsley, usually. pinkgirl22 7 years Sour Cream pinkgirl22 7 years Sour Cream ad2121 7 years little bit of onion powder, salt, and yogurt lms 7 years Wow. I never realized that people put so many different things in mashed potatoes. I like milk, butter, garlic and salt. I sometimes use chicken stock instead of the milk. rothchild 7 years roasted garlic rothchild 7 years roasted garlic michichan 7 years A1 sauce? Holy crow, what a kick. demeter 7 years I make the best baked potatoes ever!!! I mix butter, sour cream, cream cheese, shredded cheese, and sometimes pepper and seasoned salt. I am nowhere near a potato purist! haha aoitenshi 7 years I love mashed potatoes with gravy! ebur47 7 years Rutabagas are awesome with mashed potatoes and butter. k-huffman 7 years For the holidays, I keep in simple with just cream and butter. Homemade gravy and simple mashed potatoes is the perfect combo: no help needed. But when it's just me, I throw whatever I have in.