POPSUGAR Food Poll Would You Rather Eat Crunchy or Creamy Peanut Butter? by partysugar 2/21/10 4 Shares Like us on Facebook Read More Would You RatherPeanut ButterSnacksPoll Get inspired with our daily newsletter DIY Tech Home Vegetarian Love and Sex Food Sign up with By signing up, I agree to the Terms and to receive emails from POPSUGAR. What’s Your Reaction? Thanks for your reaction Don’t forget to share this with your friends! 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Reactions bluewombat 3 years I like both, although I prefer creamy, as it preserves the illusion of eating whole roasted nuts. Am writing a book about the history of peanut butter; my website is www.creamyandcrunchy.com 4 years its just wrong to eat crunchy L0neLyHeArT 5 years I like creamy peanut butter. Monique-Marie427757 5 years Creamy is the best!! suziryder 5 years I prefer crunchy, but I like smooth almost just as much. I love peanut butter! Where I'm a big stickler is JIF v. Skippy. I hate Jif. I think it tastes off, funky, almost spoiled. I prefer Skippy natural or Trader Joe's valencia peanuts natural. PinkNC 5 years I like both. GlowingMoon 5 years These days, creamy. I go back and forth, though. medenginer 5 years Creamy socalbeachgal 5 years Crunchy please but usually buy creamy for my son so I don't eat it too often. KadBunny 5 years Creamy please! Mmm by the spoonful. :P Love-and-Sex 5 years I was juuuust talking about this today. Crunchy please! Rancher'sGirl 5 years Super Crunchy in cookies, creamy on my toast and in sandwiches...and fuzzles is spot on about creamy on toast with BACON BACON BACON! :drool: fuzzles 5 years Creamy. On toast. With...BACON! :true: Spectra 5 years Chunky! When we were growing up, my dad would only buy the chunky kind because that's what he liked. So it's kind of grown on me. njg1rl65 5 years Love creamy but use chunky when making peanut butter cookies. HoneyBrown1976 5 years Creamy. But, I must admit to having a crunchy phrase in my life. limelindsey 5 years Creamy! My mom found out early that I didn't like crunchy....she made me a PBJ for lunch when I was probably 3 years old. She looked at my plate afterwards and asked me what the little chunks were. I said I didn't like the rocks! I had eaten the entire sandwich but had spit the peanut chunks out! After that she had to buy two kinds of peanut butter. Good times. gingirl 5 years Creamy all the way! I hate the chunks for some reason. Peanut butter on toast with cinnamon and sugar sprinkled on top is my favorite snack. lilxmissxmolly 5 years Creamy almond butter is the biznass neonbee 5 years Crunchy. msshellokitty 5 years creamy rainydaybleus 5 years i prefer crunchy, but yet we always have cream in the house. strange. beckkii 5 years allergic!