Skip Nav
Food Video
Eat Your Heart Out With These Nutella-Stuffed Doughnuts
Duff Goldman
Duff Goldman's Baking Hack Is Just as Charming as His Cakes
Food Reviews
M&M's Brand-New Flavor Will Make Caramel Fanatics Lose Their Sh*t

Would You Rather Eat Gelato or Ice Cream?

Photos by flickr user foodistablog and flickr user WayTru

Around The Web
Join The Conversation
AlexisSF AlexisSF 7 years
ice cream — a little melted like the picture. my favorite flavors are coffee, vanilla bean, choc chip cookie dough and rocky road.
ilanac13 ilanac13 7 years
i actually like both and would have which ever one was around. i think that there's a good difference between either that makes it a great treat in the summer.
prencesschris prencesschris 7 years
gelato is healthier for i heard.
sarahlea81 sarahlea81 7 years
we moved to Germany 3 years ago...and once you try gelato, you are ruined for life. :) I could eat it everyday.
ella1978 ella1978 7 years
jessrose. been there. awesome! We have a gelato shop not far from our house. It's really good. A bunch of us went not to long ago, they had pink grapefruit, it was wonderful. Tart and creamy! But I love both.
Linda-McP Linda-McP 7 years
Gelato, but I do love both.
Baby-Girl Baby-Girl 7 years
It depends what I'm in the mood for. Both are great.
victork victork 7 years
Gelato, though I'm a sucker for a good chocolate chip cookie dough. However, if it's in public, and after a meal, I'll opt for a sorbet, just so I don't feel so bloated after.
nicky360 nicky360 7 years
I like both but I have a summer addiction to Paciugo!
spacebear spacebear 7 years
yum! Amy's ice cream is wonderful! i guess it all just depends on what kinda mood i am in.
Sofia-Soubrette Sofia-Soubrette 7 years
Magycmyste Magycmyste 7 years
agreeing with insanitypepper - my preference is gelato, but I'll eat them both! (Actually, I probably eat ice cream more often anyway - just makes the gelato more special when I have it!
insanitypepper insanitypepper 7 years
I like gelato better, but I definitely won't complain if you hand me an ice cream cone.
PinkNC PinkNC 7 years
Ice Cream for now. I've never tried the other to my knowledge.
dani17731 dani17731 7 years
I picked ice cream because I don't really remember ever having gelato. If I did it was long ago, and it must not have 'wow'ed me. I just love ice dream.
GlowingMoon GlowingMoon 7 years
Neither. I don't like frozen desserts. I guess I eat too slow as it melts into liquid on me.
miamixo miamixo 7 years
I love em both
Spectra Spectra 7 years
Gelato, hands down. Once you try it, it's sort of addicting and nothing else can compare to it. It's absolutely fabulous!
HoneyBrown1976 HoneyBrown1976 7 years
JessRose JessRose 7 years
Gelato. From Vivoli in Florence. Best.
sassbidefan89 sassbidefan89 7 years
Gelato is amazing, when i came back from Rome, i refused to eat ice cream, it doesn't compare
candy2007 candy2007 7 years
Ice cream. I agree with simplyfab87 I've never had the opportunity to try gelato.
simplyfab87 simplyfab87 7 years
Ice cream. I've never had gelato but I've always want to try it but never had the opportunity
What Guy Fieri Eats For Breakfast
Spaghetti With Garlic White Wine Sauce Recipe
Selena Gomez Wearing a Swimsuit
The Best Avocado Toast Recipes
Easy Roasted Fig and Goat Cheese Recipe
How to Make a Mason Jar Salad
Taking the Perfect Nail Photo | Video

POPSUGAR, the #1 independent media and technology company for women. Where more than 75 million women go for original, inspirational content that feeds their passions and interests.

From Our Partners
Latest Food
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds