POPSUGAR Food Poll Would You Rather Eat Mashed Potatoes Or Twice Baked Potatoes? by partysugar 8/12/07 0 Shares Like us on Facebook Image Source Read More Twice Baked PotatoesWould You RatherPotatoesMashed PotatoesPoll Get inspired with our daily newsletter Love and Sex Food Tech DIY Vegetarian Home Sign up with By signing up, I agree to the Terms and to receive emails from POPSUGAR. MrsJigglesworth 7 years mashed kiddylnd 7 years BOTH please! I love my mashed with lots of sour cream. We make ours with the skin on too, which is my absolute favorite. MMMmmmmm....love me some taters. theboyslover 7 years i love potatoes period. which is bad considering i'm diabetic >__< ktownpolarbear 7 years mashed or once-baked. i don't like the twice baked all that much. they're too overloaded usually. ALSW 7 years Mashed and made by my grandmother. Those are the best! butterflyforaday 7 years baked and loaded with all the fixins. TexasTwinkle 7 years Mashed potatoes are my favorite! adelka 7 years Both! I love potatoes so much :) I-LOVE-JAKE-G 7 years BOTH!!! I love potato! partysugar 7 years Esagashi: my dad makes a mean twice baked potato too! I'm all about the twice baked. sugarfan 7 years Mashed, fo sho! cravinsugar 7 years I LOVE twice baked. The way my mom fixes them, the potatoes get to be a light golden color on top (no extra cheese needed, that pick does NOt look yummy yum!)and the potato skin gets a bit crispy. DELISH! ccsugar 7 years MASHED!!! With lots of garlic and rosemary! herjoiedevivre 7 years twice baked!! I had some yesterday leftover from my boyfriend's grandmother, who is the best southern cook I've EVER tasted....yummmm :) Esagashi 7 years By the fact that mashed are winning, I know that my father's twice bakes will need to be served more often and to more people. The trick is to cut the taters in 1/2, bake, scoop (but don't scoop too much, or you'll tear the skin), mix the filling with extra sharp cheddar, sour cream, salt, white pepper, and butter, then put back into the skins and bake again. You want the filling to be molten, the skin to be crisp, and to never choose mashed over twice-baked again. ;^) Chiquita-82 7 years mashed, but i cook it in a different way... yummy! millarci 7 years OMG! I looooooove mashed potatoes (homemade, not from the box) ! Especially during Turkey day! YUM-O! ;) saffy1227 7 years mashed chiefdishwasher 7 years They both can really have almost the same ingredients and taste very similar. I am sure both can be very fattening as you add different types of cheese, bacon, sour cream, onions, garlic etc. Twice baked are my favorite when topped with cheese and bacon. nikkih 7 years I choose both! sarahkushner 7 years I can only have ONE?!?!?!?! lms 7 years Garlic mashed potatoes are my favorite. xmeghanx 7 years Mashed Megatron 7 years Don't make me decide!! But, if I were forced into a decision, I think I would go with twice baked tooq2love 7 years i love them both, but if given a choice i prefer twice baked.