POPSUGAR Food Candy Would You Rather Eat Peeps or Cadbury Creme Eggs? by partysugar 4/12/09 0 Shares Like us on Facebook Source and Source Read More Cadbury Creme EggsPeepsEasterWould You RatherPollCandy Candy Sweetest Summer Treat: Gummy Bear Popsicles Reese's Peanut Butter Cup Blondies. Enough Said. 4-Ingredient Chocolate Salted Caramels That Are Actually Healthy 11 Reasons It Was Sweet to Be a '90s Kid Get inspired with our daily newsletter Love and Sex Vegetarian Food Home Tech DIY Sign up with By signing up, I agree to the Terms and to receive emails from POPSUGAR. 5 years Cadburys cream eggs, cos i've never heard of the other cutefactory 5 years Jelly beans and Mary Sue Easter Eggs-- vanilla nougat rolled in pecans and caramel Allytta 6 years i have never eaten neither of them :) so i don't know. Trixr4kidz 6 years Cadbury mini eggs. Yum. cdent4 6 years jelly beans all the way! aimeeb 6 years I'm with amloveaffair!!! muse2323 6 years I love Cadbury Mini Eggs! I argued with my husband that we should get some before Easter because they're always sold out after, and he said he was certain there would be, and they're be on sale then. So I sent him out this morning to the store, and he called me to tell me I was right--they were all out. (Then he asked if he was still allowed to come home.) amandaaa 6 years BOTH but i prefer cadbury eggs! juliarose23 6 years i adooore cadbury creme eggs, and i can't eat peeps anyway because they contain gelatin. i know what peeps taste like though, and cadbury creme eggs are much much better. suziryder 6 years Cadbury cream eggs all the way!! Only the traditional kind, though, I'm not a fan of the fake caramel. The chocolate filled cadbury cream eggs were good, but they seem to have disappeared. Peeps are gross IMO. LaLaLaurie06 6 years I love Peeps, but nothing beats chocolate and that delicious filling! ilanac13 6 years neither. i've tried both in the past and really didn't enjoy either. i guess i'm not that kind of a 'sweets' person. 6 years Cadburys Mini Eggs!! (the U.K ones) angelaminx 6 years I have no desire to eat a peep or cadbury egg but I find the Reese's Egg addictive and I think its best for me they are only available at Easter. opentypeA 6 years I just had a chocolate peep for the first time today! Honestly, if I wasn't in the room with a bunch of people, I probably would've spit it out -- the texture just doesn't do it for me. Maybe if it was frozen, but eating a big wad of sugar-mush...I just don't get how people can do it... Antioxidant 6 years Peeps are nasty, and Cadbury Creme Eggs are soo sweet it almost hurts. I'd have to go with neither. starangel82 6 years Peeps. Spectra 6 years Cadbury Eggs!! I love those things. I eat at least one or two a week during Easter season. Peeps are OK, but they don't really taste like much to me. SKC-Sparkle 6 years Both are nasty. I prefer regular chocolate eggs (especially dark chocolate). Or the Cadbury mini eggs. Rancher'sGirl 6 years See's Dark Chocolate with Maple Sugar Creme! :drool: Oh, and Spiced Jelly Beans! UrbanBohemian 6 years Peeps are gross. I always love the classic Cadbury egg. The Reester bunny is a new favorite though :-) FshLover09 6 years Peeps taste weird and kinda like what plastic would taste like....lol. Cadbury caramel eggs are the best!! burningphoenix 6 years Chocolate bunnies! TeejayR 6 years i'm a jelly bean person msshellokitty 6 years neither.i have never had a peep or a creme egg.i like the reese's.