Skip Nav
Get the Dish
Can't Get Your Hands on Cookie Dough Kit Kats? Make Your Own!
Fast and Easy
Salmon With Crispy Cabbage and Kale Is a 1-Pan Wonder
Toast to Spring With These Strawberry Margaritas

Would You Rather Eat Pot Pie or Shepherd's Pie?

Would You Rather Eat Pot Pie or Shepherd's Pie?

Source: Flickr Users gtrwndr87 and randomduck

Around The Web
Join The Conversation
CanadianAlissa CanadianAlissa 7 years
i dislike crust. No pie of any kind for me... Shepherd's Pie for me.
orangek8 orangek8 7 years
Mmm, shepherd's for me, please.
Neuroticone Neuroticone 7 years
I've never had Shepherd Pie but it sounds good.
melissaS melissaS 7 years
I like them both, but if I had to pick one I would have to choose shepherd's pie. Gotta have mashed potatoes :)
limelindsey limelindsey 7 years
Shepherd's pie! But mainly because I LOVE mashed potatoes. The insides are basically the same - meat, veggies, gravy.
Pallas-Athena Pallas-Athena 7 years
I love both, but I think I'd rather have pot pie.
victork victork 7 years
Shephard's pie, but damn, this is one difficult toss up. While I like sweet pies, I'm never able to pass up a good savoury pie. While it may not follow the shephard's pie recipe to the letter, I love the mash up of having a pastry bottom with the shephard pie top.
Spectra Spectra 7 years
I don't eat lamb/sheep so shepherd's pie is out for me. I don't eat pot pie either though...I just don't really care much for savory pies, I guess.
anon321 anon321 7 years
Both are good, but I prefer pot pie the PA Dutch way with dough noodles instead of a crust.
HoneyBrown1976 HoneyBrown1976 7 years
Where's the both option? They are both good!! I voted pot pie, though.
Niami Niami 7 years
I liked homemade pot pies, but the gluten-free versions (homemade or store bought) suck.
simplyfab87 simplyfab87 7 years
Pot pies have always weirded me out. I really want to try shepherd's pie, it looks delicious.
kurniakasih kurniakasih 7 years
Unfair! I love 'em both. I can't be made to choose...:drool:
doogirl doogirl 7 years
Not fair! I love them both equally!
justanerd1975 justanerd1975 7 years
I chose pot pie, but I really do like both so hard choice! :)
cupcake_ cupcake_ 7 years
I LOVE shepards pie!
CoconutPie CoconutPie 7 years
Chicken pot pie is my favorite! The Québec version of a Shepherd's pie is a close second though - ground beef + creamed corn + mashed potatoes (to be eaten with a lot of ketchup). :feedme:
miznic miznic 7 years
No way! - We have to choose just one? I love them both... especially when they're homemade!
AMP AMP 7 years
pot pie although ill probably never have it again after learning how many fat n calories are in it
Ramen Pot Pie Recipe
How to Make Chicken Pot Pie
Leftovers Turkey Pot Pie Recipe
Vegetarian Pot Pie Recipe
52 Weeks of Baking: Two Turkey Pies
Monday's Leftovers: Lamb Pot Pie
Monday's Leftovers: Lamb Pot Pie

POPSUGAR, the #1 independent media and technology company for women. Where more than 75 million women go for original, inspirational content that feeds their passions and interests.

From Our Partners
Latest Food
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds