Skip Nav
OREO
Oreos Makes a Chocolate Chip Cookie Flavor — But Is It Any Good?
Get the Dish
Pumpkin Spice Truffles When You Don't Want to Bother With Baking Pie
Dominique Ansel
Our Take on the Cronut — the Easiest Homemade Version Yet

Would You Rather Eat Pumpkin or Pecan Pie?

Source: Flickr Users delgaudm and museinthecity

Around The Web
Join The Conversation
muse2323 muse2323 6 years
I love both, but pecan pie is so sweet and rich that it only takes a few bites before I'm done.
jennythereader jennythereader 6 years
I'll have apple or cherry, please.
BRANDYNICOLE730 BRANDYNICOLE730 6 years
I'll take both! Mmmm... The last couple of years I have been making a sort of turtle pie. I just add chocolate and caramel chips to my pecan pie mixture before baking.
gingirl gingirl 6 years
I'm a huge fan of apple pie, but that wasn't an option here. I don't really like pumpkin pie all that much, so pecan is it. Last year I made pumpkin muffins with a cheesecake frosting that was a big hit, though!
Soniabonya Soniabonya 6 years
Pumpkin pie for me :) Pecan pie is too sweet for me. But I would like to give sweet potato pie a try. I never had it before. Rancher'sGirl, apple upside down cake?? That sounds yummy.
suziryder suziryder 6 years
Mm, I looove pumpkin pie! I don't really go for custardy things, so I don't find pecan pie too appealing. Also, I tend to find it to be too rich.
Rancher'sGirl Rancher'sGirl 6 years
Gingerbread and apple upside down cake sounds very droolworthy to me...or pumpkin pecan cheesecake...or even better, homemade apple crisp, Grandma's Southern-style recipe...sigh of contentment.LOL :) :drool:
Mme-Hart Mme-Hart 6 years
Both!!!!!
hypnoticmix hypnoticmix 6 years
Sweet Potato and Key Lime for me. I made a White Potato pie once that came out of left field and pleasantly surprised everyone. I got that recipe from Southern Living Magazine.
bchicgrl bchicgrl 6 years
I'll take pumpkin pie any day but I love sweet potato pie.
mek123 mek123 6 years
Pecan with sweet potato pie as second choice
insanitypepper insanitypepper 6 years
Pumpkin, pumpkin, pumpkin! I've been practicing baking my pies for Thanksgiving dinner for the past month.
Spectra Spectra 6 years
Pumpkin! It's yummy and it makes you feel a little less guilty about eating pie since it has at least some nutritional value.
aabinfl aabinfl 6 years
Give me a good old apple pie please.
neonbee neonbee 6 years
I just had too much pumpkin pie last month. I think I'm going to go for either pecan pie or apple pie.
cupcake_ cupcake_ 6 years
Pumpkin pie all the way - it's my fave :)
NurseKimberly NurseKimberly 6 years
Pecan
HoneyBrown1976 HoneyBrown1976 6 years
Pumpkin or sweet potato
GlowingMoon GlowingMoon 6 years
Oh, this is tough. I would try both. They would taste good together, too.
msshellokitty msshellokitty 6 years
Neither.I prefer sweet potato pie.
pinky8486 pinky8486 6 years
I like apple the best. Even though I'm a Southern girl, I am not a fan of pecan pie. I love pecans but I don't like the corn syrupy, gooey texture.
betty-kraker betty-kraker 6 years
i just made a homemade pumpkin pie peeling the skin off the pumpkin is so hard but so much better then the can stuff and its liter
superfoxml superfoxml 6 years
I've had a pumpkin pecan cheesecake, best of both worlds I say!
elocin85 elocin85 6 years
Both are great, but I love apple crisp. Especially with vanilla ice cream. Yum.
sonya-ina sonya-ina 6 years
I actually prefer Apple pie, but of the those 2, pumpkin! Most pumpkin pies are a bit too heavy, but my Mom makes a great pumpkin chiffon pie.
Pumpecapple Piecake Review
Alton Brown Live on Broadway
7-Day Gratitude Challenge
Vegan Gluten-Free Pumpkin Cookies
Curry Pumpkin Soup
Gratitude Cards and Gifts
Bourbon Pecan Pie

POPSUGAR, the #1 independent media and technology company for women. Where more than 75 million women go for original, inspirational content that feeds their passions and interests.

From Our Partners
Latest Food
X