POPSUGAR Food Thanksgiving Would You Rather Eat Pumpkin or Pecan Pie? by partysugar 11/08/09 0 Shares Like us on Facebook Source: Flickr Users delgaudm and museinthecity Read More Pumpkin PiePiesPecan PiePieWould You RatherDessertsThanksgivingPoll Thanksgiving Show Your Appreciation With This 7-Day Gratitude Challenge How to Easily Crimp Pie Crust, in Pictures Protein Balls + Smoothie + Cookies = 1 Can of Pumpkin Pumpkin Bars Are Like Cake With the Frosting Already Swirled In Get inspired with our daily newsletter Food Vegetarian DIY Love and Sex Tech Home Sign up with By signing up, I agree to the Terms and to receive emails from POPSUGAR. What’s Your Reaction? Thanks for your reaction Don’t forget to share this with your friends! 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Reactions muse2323 5 years I love both, but pecan pie is so sweet and rich that it only takes a few bites before I'm done. jennythereader 5 years I'll have apple or cherry, please. BRANDYNICOLE730 5 years I'll take both! Mmmm... The last couple of years I have been making a sort of turtle pie. I just add chocolate and caramel chips to my pecan pie mixture before baking. gingirl 5 years I'm a huge fan of apple pie, but that wasn't an option here. I don't really like pumpkin pie all that much, so pecan is it. Last year I made pumpkin muffins with a cheesecake frosting that was a big hit, though! Soniabonya 5 years Pumpkin pie for me :) Pecan pie is too sweet for me. But I would like to give sweet potato pie a try. I never had it before. Rancher'sGirl, apple upside down cake?? That sounds yummy. suziryder 5 years Mm, I looove pumpkin pie! I don't really go for custardy things, so I don't find pecan pie too appealing. Also, I tend to find it to be too rich. Rancher'sGirl 5 years Gingerbread and apple upside down cake sounds very droolworthy to me...or pumpkin pecan cheesecake...or even better, homemade apple crisp, Grandma's Southern-style recipe...sigh of contentment.LOL :) :drool: Mme-Hart 5 years Both!!!!! hypnoticmix 5 years Sweet Potato and Key Lime for me. I made a White Potato pie once that came out of left field and pleasantly surprised everyone. I got that recipe from Southern Living Magazine. bchicgrl 5 years I'll take pumpkin pie any day but I love sweet potato pie. mek123 5 years Pecan with sweet potato pie as second choice insanitypepper 5 years Pumpkin, pumpkin, pumpkin! I've been practicing baking my pies for Thanksgiving dinner for the past month. Spectra 5 years Pumpkin! It's yummy and it makes you feel a little less guilty about eating pie since it has at least some nutritional value. aabinfl 5 years Give me a good old apple pie please. neonbee 5 years I just had too much pumpkin pie last month. I think I'm going to go for either pecan pie or apple pie. cupcake_ 5 years Pumpkin pie all the way - it's my fave :) NurseKimberly 5 years Pecan HoneyBrown1976 5 years Pumpkin or sweet potato GlowingMoon 5 years Oh, this is tough. I would try both. They would taste good together, too. msshellokitty 5 years Neither.I prefer sweet potato pie. pinky8486 5 years I like apple the best. Even though I'm a Southern girl, I am not a fan of pecan pie. I love pecans but I don't like the corn syrupy, gooey texture. betty-kraker 5 years i just made a homemade pumpkin pie peeling the skin off the pumpkin is so hard but so much better then the can stuff and its liter superfoxml 5 years I've had a pumpkin pecan cheesecake, best of both worlds I say! elocin85 5 years Both are great, but I love apple crisp. Especially with vanilla ice cream. Yum. sonya-ina 5 years I actually prefer Apple pie, but of the those 2, pumpkin! Most pumpkin pies are a bit too heavy, but my Mom makes a great pumpkin chiffon pie.