POPSUGAR Food Poll Would You Rather Have An Ice Cream Sundae Or An Ice Cream Sandwich? by partysugar 7/08/07 1 Shares Like us on Facebook Read More Ice Cream SundaeIce Cream SandwichesWould You RatherIce CreamPoll Get inspired with our daily newsletter Tech Love and Sex Vegetarian Home DIY Food Sign up with By signing up, I agree to the Terms and to receive emails from POPSUGAR. dancer312 7 years I would rather have the ice cream sundae. I love ice cream so much that I could eat it every day. Good thing theres ice cream thats low in fat and calories. I like Edy's because it's delicious and more healthier. LaLaLaurie06 7 years for some reason i don't like traditional ice cream sandwiches. i'll do a chocolate chip cookie ice cream sandwich but i don't like the regular ones. i'd take a sundae anyday! sassy3lady 7 years Definitely both, I can never have enough ice cream Misskastar 7 years I'd rather have an ice cream sandwich but only because I get the skinny cow kind which not only is low in calories but it also has lots of fiber so I don't feel so guilty having one. If guilt wasn't an issue though...I'd have a milkshake! LOVE milkshakes. Cheetah521 7 years Ice cream sundae barely wins because of the hot fudge sauce YUM!! lms 7 years The Sundae....with strawberries, nuts and whipped cream. hvnly34 7 years LOVE ice cream sandwiches - Always have, always will! fashionhore 7 years I am not one for ice cream or chocolate, but I do indulge. I would probably forgo the ice cream and get a fruit bar or Italian Ice. I love those! UrbanBohemian 7 years The sundae, because it's more decadent. SweetPeasMom 7 years Hands down- the sundae! :drool: crispet1 7 years Sundae! Julie2812 7 years Haha..both! lala788 7 years ice cream sundae davie-k 7 years I choose the sundae, but that's cos I always like to have cookie chips dough ice cream in a sundae! bigestivediscuit 7 years Both - but I feel like the ridiculously large brownie ice cream sundae at the Cheesecake Factory satisfies both cravings! Schaianne 7 years *cry* I choose a Carl's frozen Custard!!! (Has been showcased on the Food Network before and I am lucky enough to live close (ish) by!!) spacebear 7 years a cup of Amy's ice cream....yummm LaurenG22 7 years this is like choosing bw brad pitt and johnny depp! blasphemous! MEXICANBUTTAFLY 7 years Since I just found out just cheated on me, I pick the ice cream sundae along with kleenex. LuciLu 7 years sundae! with hot fudge, rainbow sprinkles, whipped cream, and a cherry on top. mmmmmmm.... ;) liladdieshudiva 7 years Ooh, give me both! msshellokitty 7 years Both.I love ice cream sandwiches and a good sundae.I make homemade sundaes all the time.They are so good. fablavishlife 7 years OH MY the sundae is making my knees weak. Ill have both though-one for later. sweetheart_450 7 years Ice cream sandwiches. pinkflats 7 years I picked both. It's too hard to choose when photos are present.