Skip Nav
Photo 2 of 4

Carrot Cake

Many of the tasters declared the carrot cake their favorite of the five cakes and even their favorite carrot cake of all time. The robust cream-cheese frosting provided the perfect balance to the sweet, incredibly nutty cake. Some found it too nutty, while others savored the nuts, but everyone agreed that it was complex and not too sweet. One taster also noted that you "can really taste the carrot flavor — so delish!"

Photo: Nancy Einhart

All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds