Skip Nav
Women
17 Sparkly Halloween Costumes For the Shiniest Girl in the Room
Relationships
These Adorable Drawings About Dating Are Too Real
Disney
17 Tiny and Adorable Disney Princess Tattoos

Blogging For Nothing: Matthews Rejects Blogs as Sources

Chris Matthews has limits! When he's not saying things like MSNBC "is the network of the 21st century," he's upholding archaic journalism standards.

Last night on Hardball, he cut off a reporter from the NY Daily News when she introduced blogs as the source of rumors — and, yes, she clearly presented them as rumors — about Caroline Kennedy. He said, "Let's stick to journalism. I don't do that here. If it's just blogging, let's drop it."

Bringing us to the — when did blogs become big, 2002? — 7-year-old question: Do blogs have any place in news? I thought it was answered with a "yes if used properly" at least five years ago. Apparently not!

Should Chris Matthews get with the times, or should more journalists follow his (albeit one-time) return to old-school journalism?

Around The Web
Join The Conversation
snarkypants snarkypants 7 years
if you ONLY get your news from blogs, you will be misinformed much of the time. i think blogs (and wikipedia) are a great place to hear about something, but then you should seek other journalistic sources to find more information.i do think blogs are a great way to get people interested in current events. providing the links to other news sources makes it easier to get the full story.
snarkypants snarkypants 7 years
if you ONLY get your news from blogs, you will be misinformed much of the time. i think blogs (and wikipedia) are a great place to hear about something, but then you should seek other journalistic sources to find more information. i do think blogs are a great way to get people interested in current events. providing the links to other news sources makes it easier to get the full story.
snowbunny11 snowbunny11 7 years
Oh geez, I've never gotten bad information from this blog, and blogs like the Huffington Post are giant players in the way people get their news now. Many people use MSNBC's own blogs to keep up to date, so Chris Matthews is being an idiot. The only print media I get now is the Economist, because their articles are too in depth for me to be able to read online. And I only get that once a week, so if i want to be updated constantly about the news, online newspapers and blogs are a good way to go. And I like the opinion content on Huffpo, even the reporting of rumors, because honestly, most people know when something is a rumor. With the whole Caroline Kennedy thing, Huffpo acknowledged they were reporting rumors, and then listed which newspapers and sources supported what angle. Chris Matthews just thinks we're all too stupid to sort that out, and honestly I don't get why him saying something makes it that much more credible than a blog like citizensugar. End rant!
StolzeMama StolzeMama 7 years
Because if we just trust what the statement says, then why have reporters?
StolzeMama StolzeMama 7 years
He is acting holier than thou. A part of journalism is bringing up what ifs. Questioning things beyond their public statement.
MSucre MSucre 7 years
I don't see where she presents them as rumors... she says "questions."
MiketheWaiter MiketheWaiter 7 years
personally, I wish that Caroline had not dropped out. I think she would have been a real voice for the people. And I think her lack of experience was a real plus...but that's just me...Peace to all from Indiana, USA, mTw
MiketheWaiter MiketheWaiter 7 years
personally, I wish that Caroline had not dropped out. I think she would have been a real voice for the people. And I think her lack of experience was a real plus...but that's just me... Peace to all from Indiana, USA, mTw
MSucre MSucre 7 years
Chris Matthews starts out by asking if her withdrawal had anything to do with "a personal problem involving her marriage." I think he was referring to the affair rumors in the first place.
Jude-C Jude-C 7 years
I'm just waiting for his head to explode. I know it will happen one day.
StolzeMama StolzeMama 7 years
Chris Matthews??? Speaking of reliable journalism???? HA :oy:
genesisrocks genesisrocks 7 years
If some blogs prove to be reliable over time then you can trust them but look at all the misconceptions about Obama in this election. Some rumors didn't even go together, like he's Muslim but he has a crazy Christian church leader. Both can't be possible right? So yeah, just trust the reliable sources.
hypnoticmix hypnoticmix 7 years
Well he's asking her for hard reasons for why she may have stepped aside in the untimely manner that she did. I don't believe blog chatter has a place in this context but I also give her kuddos for prefecing it as rumor because that is extremely important. All too often in my day to day work and personal life I hear people conveying rumor or assumptions and I see the listener accepting the information as fact because the information was not prefaced with the disclaimer.. oh this is just a rumor or whatever. This stuff causes more grief and misunderstanding in the long run and I don't know why people haven't learned better by now.
hypnoticmix hypnoticmix 7 years
Well he's asking her for hard reasons for why she may have stepped aside in the untimely manner that she did. I don't believe blog chatter has a place in this context but I also give her kuddos for prefecing it as rumor because that is extremely important. All too often in my day to day work and personal life I hear people conveying rumor or assumptions and I see the listener accepting the information as fact because the information was not prefaced with the disclaimer.. oh this is just a rumor or whatever. This stuff causes more grief and misunderstanding in the long run and I don't know why people haven't learned better by now.
janneth janneth 7 years
Margo, very funny! Your rejection.
margokhal margokhal 7 years
Yes, if they are from a reputable source, like CNN or MSNBC or the NYT - AND it's not an opinion blog. And she DID present what was being said as not being true - that doesn't discount *all* blogs for valid information, though. By the same token, I reject Chris Matthews as a source of "news". :)
margokhal margokhal 7 years
Yes, if they are from a reputable source, like CNN or MSNBC or the NYT - AND it's not an opinion blog. And she DID present what was being said as not being true - that doesn't discount *all* blogs for valid information, though. By the same token, I reject Chris Matthews as a source of "news". :)
clarabelle98 clarabelle98 7 years
I think it truly depends on the blog. CNN or MSNBC would be good blog sources I would think, however if you're depending on Perezhilton or Dlisted or TMZ or something, well, then you probably deserve all the misinformation you get. LOL
kia kia 7 years
I think blogs are good for quick information. CNN keeps their twitter page posted near the teleprompts during broadcasts for breaking stories. My only issue with blogs and websites for information is when people use them as information sources in lieu of peer-reviewed work. That is a no-no.
kia kia 7 years
I think blogs are good for quick information. CNN keeps their twitter page posted near the teleprompts during broadcasts for breaking stories. My only issue with blogs and websites for information is when people use them as information sources in lieu of peer-reviewed work. That is a no-no.
stephley stephley 7 years
I think the 'yes if used properly' standard is okay generally - but I can also see in the case of Caroline Kennedy that Matthews would have a good sense of how reliable the blogs are and whether it would be proper to use them in this case.
janneth janneth 7 years
Let's blog about Chris Matthews!!!
Frank-y-Ava Frank-y-Ava 7 years
Relationships?? Oh like Caroline's rumored "special friend". Try again Liz.
Frank-y-Ava Frank-y-Ava 7 years
Relationships?? Oh like Caroline's rumored "special friend".Try again Liz.

POPSUGAR, the #1 independent media and technology company for women. Where more than 75 million women go for original, inspirational content that feeds their passions and interests.

From Our Partners
Latest Love
X