Skip Nav
25 Movies For a Hauntingly Hot Date Night In
24 Costume Ideas For Girls With Glasses
ben higgins
I Stayed in The Bachelor Fantasy Suite, and This Is What Happened

Come Story Telling with Me!!

Welcome to DearSugar's new feature: Come Story Telling with Me!

Every Monday I am going to start the first sentence of a continuing story that you, the readers, will then finish. Do any of you remember the Choose your Own Adventure stories? This feature is quite similar-- and at the end of the week, I will post the completed story for you all to read, laugh at, and enjoy! Be sure to read the last comment and keep the story going from there. Feel free to be as imaginative and outlandish as you please, this is meant to be fun, so ladies, have at it!

Here we go:

You're never going to believe whom I ran into Saturday night!!!!

Comment below to add the next sentence or phrase to the story

Around The Web
Join The Conversation
partysugar partysugar 9 years
When was the last time you saw each other? Talked to each other? Have you been in contact with him? I close my eyes as things around me start to get fuzzy. I cant handle all these questions right now. It's too much. "Matt," I say, "that is your name right?"
regalbeagle regalbeagle 9 years
this is going to be a little more complicated than i originally thought. your ex has a knack for disappearing and staying underground until he feels it's safe to come up for air. it could be days, weeks, even years. so the most important thing is to make sure that you are safe. now, i need to ask you a few questions...
cravinsugar cravinsugar 9 years
-well, actually, I am an FBI agent, posing as an actor. I am going to be your personal body guard until we can hunt your ex down. Although I must admit, I don't think being with you 24/7 is going to feel much like a job. I must confess-
missnomi missnomi 9 years
"...was hired to come here and get involved with you. By that guy, your ex. I am an actor, you see"
cravinsugar cravinsugar 9 years
"Before you took that shot last night, do you remember you and I were talking by the bar? while our heads were turned someone slipped GHB in your drink. You passed out cold and have been for 9 hours. Matt, your new friend was worried sick, but your ex, he split and the police are looking for to question him." I went to sit up, reeling from the news, but i had such a bad headache i immediately laid back down. "Are you kidding me? What, he was going to rape me or something?" Lucy looked down and slowly shok her head. When she looked back up I could see the fear in her eyes. "When he left the club in such a hurry, the police started to do a background investigation. The name you know him by, is an alias. He has 3 other identites, and with them 3 dead ex-girl friends. The police think he could be a serial murderer, much like a black widow, only he is doing the killing." I laid, in stunned silence as tears began to well in my eyes. I turned away, and when i did I saw a vase of beautiful roses. I turned back to Lucy "Who are they from?" At that time, Matt walks into the room and says, "They are from me. I have something to tell you also." If I thought I had heard it all, more was coming. I pushed the nurse button to get some pain medicine for my splitting headache, and Matt continued. "Our meeting was not just by chance. I...
BKNYGal BKNYGal 9 years
Are you ok? How much have you had to drink so far? Just as he says that everything starts to go silent. I feel lightheaded and then complete darkness. I awake to the sound of beep...beep...beep. As I open my eyes, I find myself in the hospital. Lucy is sitting in a chair next to the hospital bed and I can tell she was crying. Lucy..what happened? Why am I here? Sweetheart, I have something to tell you....
cravinsugar cravinsugar 9 years
the Matt saunters up, with that finely scuplpted backside, and asks if he can cut in. Of course I say yes, and we start dancing, and not just with our bodies. I am feeling super sexy right now; the music is just right, our conversation is extrememly flirty and fun, and i am saying just the right things to keep it light but sexy. Then he says to me "So, maybe we should rethink our relationship-" and for one horrifying moment I am thinking to myself I am going to be dumped by someone who isn't even my boyfriend and he continues, -"and make it official" as he says that I am momentarily breathless-and balance-less, and I step sideways at an angle that causes to me trip over my own feet and fall. I can feel my face turn a bright crimson, and thinking i just blew the whole thing-I mean who would want to be with me the rest of the night after that? I am the girl who fell. As I go to stand up, he bends over to help me, and we bump heads. At this point all I can do is laugh, and instead of wallowing in my embarassment, I pull him down onto the floor with me and do something that is rarely in my repetoire-I kiss him. passionately. Then he looks at me and says...
lickety-split lickety-split 9 years
maybe it's the drink, but suddenly i feel like this is "my night", and it shows. i make my way to the dance floor and immediately a hot guy joins me there and starts dancing with me. the music makes me feel free. the lighs and the people are like a kaleidoscope; colorful, constantly moving, beautiful. i wonder why i had ever been worried about where the night might go.
cravinsugar cravinsugar 9 years
"Okay, look. The worst that can happen is that your pal Matt tells your ex he isn't really your boyfriend. It would be embarrasing, yes, but seriuosly, do you think he is doing that?" I look over, and Matt and my ex seem to be in a serious conversation-there is no laughing, no pointing or staring. I catch Matt's eye and he winks at me, and I know then that i am safe--for now. I said "You are right! give me that red headed slut and lets start this party!" We take our shots, and walk toward the group.
partysugar partysugar 9 years
As we leave the bathroom I am shocked to see Matt, Ben and my ex chatting!!! Every expletive runs through my mind. Lucy notices my deer in the headlight face and steers me towards the bar for more champagne and one of her famous pep talks. She says,
cravinsugar cravinsugar 9 years
there is a window near the sink i could climb through and go MIA for the night, but I did not get a pedi and mani just to let it go to waste in my pajamas...besides, if I went home I would end up eating a pint of Ben & Jerry's in my PJs and my hips def didn't need that..esp since they look oh so good in this little dress. I decided to suck it up and see what else could happen. I would say it couldn't get worse...but then it did...
lickety-split lickety-split 9 years
i tell her to come clean. "what is going on!" i demand. "o relax!" she tells me, as she puckers, paints and pouts in the mirror. "besides" she says with a raised eyebrow "when you see who else is here tonight this will all seem like a drop in the glass". holy crap, i'm thinking, why didn't i just stay home tonight? she grabs my hand and leads me back out the door "wild women coming through" she announces. i consider my options.....
popgoestheworld popgoestheworld 9 years
Lucy dishes on her conversation with the ex. Turns out he's back in town for a wedding, and the bachelor party is at Magnolia tonight. And to make matters worse, Lucy mentions that Ben told her earlier that week at work that he was going to be out on Saturday for a bachelor party. Could it be my new hot duo of saviors is actually with the same group that my ex is in? I guess the world can get smaller. Lucy and I finally reach the lounge in the swanky bathroom, and...
tati33 tati33 9 years
we run into my ex. He nonchalantly asks me more information about Matt. "Where is he from & what does he do?" I try to evade the question since I obviously know nothing about him & I pull on Lucy's arm to help me out but she isn't really paying attention to me because she's looking at all the other eye candy in the place. So I say,
KWM KWM 9 years
"Hi Lucy!" and gives her a huge hug hello! It turns out that they are co-workers! Could the world get any smaller. Well, I guess we don't need to figure out who's boy is who's, unless Lucy is in to the whole office romance thing. Still, a conference is in order, I grab Lucy to head to the bathroom. One our way,
partysugar partysugar 9 years
Just as I was starting to feel super overwhelmed by the situation (and the thought of possibly ending up in one of these Matt/Ben look alike's bed later that night) Lucy shows up champy in hand. "Why, hello gentlemen," she says with her maneater look in the face. I see her checking out both guys and wonder if it's too soon to bathroom break and claim which one we each shall make a move on. But before I can get a word in to Lucy, Ben says suddenly,
dmartinxoxo dmartinxoxo 9 years
Oh whoops. I guess the friends name was Ben. My bad.
dmartinxoxo dmartinxoxo 9 years
"She asked me to play her boyfriend for the night to make the ex jealous", he said jokingly, I was still slightly mortified that I asked so much of a complete stranger, but he seemed into the idea. "Oh, by the way, my name is Derek, and this is my buddy Colin." Colin cuts in and slyly says, "Now that we're all acquainted lets get the party started!" Derek then shyly reminded Colin that he didn't know my name, and I timidly replied, "Madison."
UrbanBohemian UrbanBohemian 9 years
It was so loud in the club, and while I was so dazed at the sight of the Matt look-alike, I couldn't hear what he said or the name of the tall, brown-haired, strong jawed stud that walked over. I was hearing JT's "My Love" in the background, and I was definitely seeing stars. First with the Matt look-alike, and now his equally hot friend who looked like Ben Affleck! With this sudden Matt-and-Ben manwich, I thought I was an extra in Good Will Hunting! His puppy-dog eyes darted over to the Matt clone, he said, "So what does this hot babe wish of us?"
nicachica nicachica 9 years
So the Matt Damon clone takes my hand and pulls me closely to him tightly and says "My darling, you look wonderful tonight. Wait until i get you home and the real party begins..." I look around and my ex-boyfriend is STEAMING since he was only 4 feet away! He storms up to me and the Damon clone and...
Tech Tech 9 years
"Well of course, let me go ask my friend Ben to join us."
partysugar partysugar 9 years
"So sorry," I say quickly as we look into each other's eyes. Instant chemistry sparks and I know it's now or never. "So I need you to do me a favor, my asshole ex boyfriend is back in town and thinks I have a new boyfriend and that today is his birthday. Can you play the part? I bat my eyelashes flirtatously hoping that the Matt Damon look alike is up for anything. He replies,
Celebrity Celebrity 9 years
I was so focused on my quest that I smacked right into the hottest guy I had ever seen - a dead ringer for Matt Damon in The Bourne Identity!
popgoestheworld popgoestheworld 9 years
Now the only thing I needed to complete the lie was a man. A man who would be willing to, on the spot, pretend it was his birthday, and pretend he was with me for that matter. So I left Lucy to catch up with the ex and went off to find myself a unwitting suspect.
dmartinxoxo dmartinxoxo 9 years
After a few moments of sheer panic, Lucy finally got the message and made her way over to me with two champagne cocktails in hand. I was relieved that I didn't have to be in his presence completely sober. She handed me the drink and told me that the celebration was beginning.
Bald Bride's Wedding Photos (Video)
Newlyweds Moving In Together
Tech Obsession Study
Best Sex, Love, and Dating Tips From 2011
How to Avoid a Holiday Sex Slump
Teen Sexting Facts and Figures
List of European Traditions

POPSUGAR, the #1 independent media and technology company for women. Where more than 75 million women go for original, inspirational content that feeds their passions and interests.

From Our Partners
Latest Love
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds