Skip Nav

This or That: The Planned or Spontaneous Proposal?

Ever since you met your boyfriend, you’ve had quite a few fantasies about your potential future proposal. And although some of your daydreams have been over the top, you consider yourself a down-to-earth girl who would be happy with any kind of proposal. Except, now that the moment’s arrived, you realize you would have liked things to happen a little differently. Would it be worse if . . .

This: He really went all out in terms of planning, except it's on the big screen at a sporting event — his favorite of course — that you happen to hate? You’re not sure if he was thinking more about you or his beloved team.

Or . . .

That: He goes the spontaneous route when, after an amazing bedroom session, he throws off the covers and gets down on one knee totally nude and pops the question? Ok, you know he loves you, but is this just lust talking?

Which is worse?

To see all of our wedding coverage, check out


Latest Love
Looking for the perfect gift this holiday season? Order our POPSUGAR Must Have box now >>