Skip Nav
Watch These '90s Romances on Netflix If You're Ready For a Lot of Feelings
2016 Presidential Debates
17 Fabulous Items For the "Nasty Women" of America
JK Rowling
The Wizard J.K. Rowling Said Dumbledore Was in Love With Will Shock You

Poll: Do You Vote With Your Gut?

Scientific research suggests that we vote with our guts. In other words, our voting decisions are impacted more by anxiety and enthusiasm than by reason or logic. If we can identify with a candidate, we are more likely to vote for him or her.

According to Newsweek, most people have "cognitive-processing limitations" — meaning we cannot or will not learn about and remember candidates' records or positions. Um, whatever. I have a feeling it has more to do with the fact that politicians tailor their message depending on which crowd they're speaking to — or perhaps it's a result of the 24-hour news circuit, which replays irrelevant gaffs or tears over and over again.

So if we're not conducting detailed policy analysis, and political party affiliation doesn't matter in primaries, how do we chose a candidate?

This year, issue positions aren't much of a help, because the candidates don't differ that much (making my decision that much more difficult!!). So, we're left with the personality factor. Various scholars contend that we choose the candidate that we identify with, or that makes us feel good. The article offers this priceless example from the 1976 primaries.

While campaigning in Texas, Ford ate, or tried to eat, a tamale without first removing its corn-husk wrapper. He nearly choked on it. Mexican-American voters inferred from this — reasonably — that Ford didn't know much about them or their culture, and that it therefore made sense to pull the lever for Reagan.

So, how many of you vote with your gut?


Around The Web
Join The Conversation
rickimc rickimc 8 years
Wow, I totally voted with my gut today and did not even realize I was doing it.
usernamelisa usernamelisa 8 years
i will never vote with my gut. that's what got bush elected in the first place. people thought he would be a nice guy to hang out with and transferred that to being a good prez somehow. i think that campaigning is such a crazy and unforgiving atmosphere that a candidate can't be properly judged based on campaign trail behavior, so i vote based on past actions.
Candybee Candybee 8 years
When their positions are close, I go with my gut. I can't help it. I read all about the candidates platforms and learn everything I can about them. But, when it comes to Barack and Hillary, I cannot decide & therefore will probably vote w/ my gut. Vote for the one that inspires me the most.
Princesskitty22 Princesskitty22 8 years
I vote based on a lot of things; one of those is the feeling they give me. However, it is not the most important thing by a long shot.
lizadilly lizadilly 8 years
Actually, Newsweek has a point, although I agree that we often HAVE to rely on our gut because politicians aren't straightforward. But there have been studies that show that people on both sides of the political spectrum involuntarily block out new information if it conflicts with their established ideals. One reason why bipartisan cooperation is harder than it sounds!
Barack Obama on Check Please! Chicago
Candidates Broke Late-Night Show Appearance Records
Favorite Barack Obama Moment of 2008: Election Night Victory Speech
Favorite John McCain Moment of 2008: His Graceful Concession Speech
Favorite Sarah Palin Moment of 2008: Sarah Meets the Press
Most Shocking Headlines of 2008: Bristol Palin Is With Child
Biggest News Story: Tech Takes Over the Election

POPSUGAR, the #1 independent media and technology company for women. Where more than 75 million women go for original, inspirational content that feeds their passions and interests.

From Our Partners
Latest Love
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds