Skip Nav
Summer
The 31 Books You MUST Put in Your Beach Bag This Summer!
Wedding
These High School Sweethearts Had the MOST Romantic Garden Wedding
Relationships
40 Hilarious Costumes For the Funniest Couples

Should Low-Income Students Be Paid to Study?

Students from low-income families are being offered $8 an hour to do their homework. A Georgia based nonprofit group, Learn to Earn, wants to get kids into study sessions by offering them some cash, with the hope that they'll enjoy learning once in the classroom.

Despite positive student feedback, the program— developed by the daughter of former House Speaker Newt Gingrich — bothers some educators. Some argue that it treats low-income students like servants of the better off, and reinforces the idea that they are destined to be wage earners.

I don't think money motivation is necessarily bad, as it can reduce financial pressure felt by some students. It kills two birds with one check — students can earn money as if they had an after-school job, without taking time away from school.

Do you think something like this should be available to all students, regardless of their families' economic situations? Are you happy to see low-income students focusing on school, regardless of the motivation?

Source

Around The Web
Join The Conversation
pinklady8287 pinklady8287 7 years
I am totally against this. I believe that students should be taught to do their homework for the sake of learning. Good grades should be the reward! This is absolutely ridiculous!
Big-Ben Big-Ben 8 years
I can appreciate the intentions behind this, but I feel that it is short-sighted and misguided. I think this ultimately sends the wrong message to the students; young people need to understand that the benefits gained from getting a good education far outweigh financial rewards, and in the end it is only in their best interest to do well. I agree with some of the points already made: perhaps a better use of that money would be to put it back into the school systems. It seems almost insulting to pay some kid $8 an hour to do something he or she is supposed to be doing anyways, while teachers are still grossly underpaid and educational programs like art, music and phys ed are being cut all over the country. Perhaps they could start some other kind of rewards program for students' academic achievements, like maybe giving out gift cards to food or clothing stores or local restaurants to help offset their families' cost of living expenses (not to stereotype, but trusting a teenager to do the right thing and be sensible with a pocket full of cash is akin to trusting a lion not to attack you while wearing a suit made of raw meat.) Perhaps they could use this money to establish more scholarship and financial aid programs so that kids who want to go on to college or private schools can do so without their families falling even deeper into debt. If we want to improve the state of our nation, we need to create an environment where any kid from any type of background can have access to quality education. So while I agree with one poster here who observed that at least doing something is better than continuing to do nothing, I can't help but feel that a program like this will ultimately backfire.
Big-Ben Big-Ben 8 years
I can appreciate the intentions behind this, but I feel that it is short-sighted and misguided. I think this ultimately sends the wrong message to the students; young people need to understand that the benefits gained from getting a good education far outweigh financial rewards, and in the end it is only in their best interest to do well. I agree with some of the points already made: perhaps a better use of that money would be to put it back into the school systems. It seems almost insulting to pay some kid $8 an hour to do something he or she is supposed to be doing anyways, while teachers are still grossly underpaid and educational programs like art, music and phys ed are being cut all over the country. Perhaps they could start some other kind of rewards program for students' academic achievements, like maybe giving out gift cards to food or clothing stores or local restaurants to help offset their families' cost of living expenses (not to stereotype, but trusting a teenager to do the right thing and be sensible with a pocket full of cash is akin to trusting a lion not to attack you while wearing a suit made of raw meat.) Perhaps they could use this money to establish more scholarship and financial aid programs so that kids who want to go on to college or private schools can do so without their families falling even deeper into debt. If we want to improve the state of our nation, we need to create an environment where any kid from any type of background can have access to quality education. So while I agree with one poster here who observed that at least doing something is better than continuing to do nothing, I can't help but feel that a program like this will ultimately backfire.
hartsfull hartsfull 8 years
Am I the only one who doesn't mind this idea??? As Liberty said it doesn't come from tax payers so, to me if someone wants to put money to education then, yeay. I don't like the fact that it only bennies low income students. I just think it should be for all kids. We give our daughter rewards for good grades, good dental checkups etc. I don't think there's anything wrong with incentives coming from different directions. Yeah, more things for public schools would be nice. But, that doesn't really BRING a kids attention to better themselves. Maybe it does encourage the idea that "money makes the world go around" but just because something isn't perfect, I dont' think it necessarily means to scrap it.I just think if someone wants to do something good with their own money, more power to them.
hartsfull hartsfull 8 years
Am I the only one who doesn't mind this idea??? As Liberty said it doesn't come from tax payers so, to me if someone wants to put money to education then, yeay. I don't like the fact that it only bennies low income students. I just think it should be for all kids. We give our daughter rewards for good grades, good dental checkups etc. I don't think there's anything wrong with incentives coming from different directions. Yeah, more things for public schools would be nice. But, that doesn't really BRING a kids attention to better themselves. Maybe it does encourage the idea that "money makes the world go around" but just because something isn't perfect, I dont' think it necessarily means to scrap it. I just think if someone wants to do something good with their own money, more power to them.
tlsgirl tlsgirl 8 years
I really think it should be equal. Put the money into schools to help them improve, or help all children pay for books and other costs of schooling. The whole idea as is is just ridiculous.
ennabeatriz ennabeatriz 8 years
I understand what everyone is saying but I think it makes sense. There has to be a reward system that works to encourage people to want to learn. What would be great would be if the kids were set up with bank accounts as scholarships or trusts.
ennabeatriz ennabeatriz 8 years
I understand what everyone is saying but I think it makes sense. There has to be a reward system that works to encourage people to want to learn. What would be great would be if the kids were set up with bank accounts as scholarships or trusts.
Jude-C Jude-C 8 years
Laine:For bold, you put a "b" between <> at the beginning of the word/phrase you want bolded, and "/b" between <> at the end. (Without quotation marks.)For italics, it's "i" between <> at the start, and "/i" between <> at the end.
Jude-C Jude-C 8 years
Laine: For bold, you put a "b" between <> at the beginning of the word/phrase you want bolded, and "/b" between <> at the end. (Without quotation marks.) For italics, it's "i" between <> at the start, and "/i" between <> at the end.
Cassandra57 Cassandra57 8 years
Oh, and all you smart people: What kind of code do you use for bold and italic fonts?
Cassandra57 Cassandra57 8 years
Education has value in itself; it is a gift. Should you be paid to accept a gift? Also, if anything, they should be rewarded for *results* (i.e., grades), not just time. Also, I'm sick to death of being screwed at both ends. We're not poor enough to qualify for all these special programs, or wealthy enough to pay for enrichment programs. My kids are both bright, but we are not able to provide them with all the opportunities I feel they deserve and need to reach their potential. hypnotic: Education (at least in California) may have been underfunded for years, now, but the money they *do* have is not well spent. I look at this stuff *every day*, so I see how it works. :rant:
Cassandra57 Cassandra57 8 years
Education has value in itself; it is a gift. Should you be paid to accept a gift? Also, if anything, they should be rewarded for *results* (i.e., grades), not just time. Also, I'm sick to death of being screwed at both ends. We're not poor enough to qualify for all these special programs, or wealthy enough to pay for enrichment programs. My kids are both bright, but we are not able to provide them with all the opportunities I feel they deserve and need to reach their potential. hypnotic: Education (at least in California) may have been underfunded for years, now, but the money they *do* have is not well spent. I look at this stuff *every day*, so I see how it works. :rant:
jennifer76 jennifer76 8 years
I'm a little torn. The idea here kind of offends me. And it definitely isn't sending a great message.At the same time, sitting back and saying that regardless of whatever <em>is</em> happening, parents and educators <em>should</em> be reinforcing the value of education feels a little like saying <em>my kids are lucky to have parents who care about their education and fuck all them other kids</em>.
jennifer76 jennifer76 8 years
I'm a little torn. The idea here kind of offends me. And it definitely isn't sending a great message. At the same time, sitting back and saying that regardless of whatever is happening, parents and educators should be reinforcing the value of education feels a little like saying my kids are lucky to have parents who care about their education and fuck all them other kids.
UnDave35 UnDave35 8 years
I think it sends the wrong message on several levels. And what happens when my kids get to school, and I am dollars above the poverty level. Do they get paid to study?
UnDave35 UnDave35 8 years
I think it sends the wrong message on several levels. And what happens when my kids get to school, and I am dollars above the poverty level. Do they get paid to study?
annebreal annebreal 8 years
Ummmm...who cares if a man is footing the bill? I don't care if it was a man or a woman who developed the program, either, although it was a woman.
LibertySugar LibertySugar 8 years
Hey fuzzles,I was just relaying information about the specific program, i.e. that a man offered the financing. From <b>NPR</b>: <blockquote>Cushman launched Learn and Earn this year after an Atlanta businessman offered to sponsor it, and Creekside High School in Fairburn, Ga., and neighboring Bear Creek Middle School fit the right profile for it.</blockquote>
LibertySugar LibertySugar 8 years
Hey fuzzles, I was just relaying information about the specific program, i.e. that a man offered the financing. From NPR:
Cushman launched Learn and Earn this year after an Atlanta businessman offered to sponsor it, and Creekside High School in Fairburn, Ga., and neighboring Bear Creek Middle School fit the right profile for it.
Kimpossible Kimpossible 8 years
even as an individually funded private charity I still think it's a bad idea.
Twinkle1 Twinkle1 8 years
If it will keep more kids in school, I'm all for it.
fuzzles fuzzles 8 years
No disrespect Liberty, but for me a "businessWOMAN" would have a bit more credibility. Particularly when most teachers have breasticles.
LibertySugar LibertySugar 8 years
FYI, this is not a tax-payer program. A businessman is backing the non-profit. It's a private charity.
leeluvfashion leeluvfashion 8 years
Hate this idea. We shouldn't have to pay kids to study. Take up an after-school job and a weekend job and you can earn money that way. Learning is a gift and we shouldn't have to pay kids to appreicate it.
Review of Bagrationi Sparkling Wine
Georgia Considers English-Only Driver's Test — Why?
Front Page: Georgia's Runoff For US Senate Seat Underway!
Front Page: US Unemployment Reaches Grim High at 6.5%
Despite Conflict With Russia, Georgia Has Love For Stalin
Briefing Book! Everyday Russians React to Putin and US
Should the US Push For Georgia to Join NATO?

POPSUGAR, the #1 independent media and technology company for women. Where more than 75 million women go for original, inspirational content that feeds their passions and interests.

From Our Partners
Latest Love
X