Skip Nav

Jenny and Thomas

They were in a band together, performing at their church on Mother's Day. At the end of their set, a band member made the announcement that there was one more song — Jenny was not a part of it. She stood there, wondering what was going on, until he sang "I should be over all the butterflies" (a Paramore song), and at that moment she figured out what was happening.

Get the full proposal story on How He Asked.

Photo by Emily Sacra

Read More ProposalsProposalEngagementWedding
Looking for the perfect gift this holiday season? Order our POPSUGAR Must Have box now >>