The 34-year-old father who once played a male nanny on Friends was so convincing in his portrayal that we're sure he is an outstanding father to daughter Charlotte Grace. He and wife Sara Michelle Gellar welcomed their bundle of joy in September. We hope the new family enjoys their first holidays together!
Some of our favorite celebrity dads became second or third time fathers this year, but there was a few that entered parenthood for the very first time in 2009. While they are all adorable in their own right, it was Freddie Prinze Jr. who took the prize for the Favorite New Dad of 2009.