Who Would You Want to Be Your Baby Daddy? Who Would You Pick to Play Your Baby Daddy? By babysugar Apr 26 2008 Pretend for just a minute that you're Hollywood's "IT" girl and have to choose who will play your baby daddy in an upcoming flick. Since there are plenty of Sugardaddies strutting around Tinseltown, it might be hard to choose just ONE hottie. Give it a shot!