The 2009 show was when Sacha Baron Cohen (as his character Brüno) descended from the rafters and put his bare butt in Eminem's face. The rapper was in on the stunt but acted so upset during the show that we had no idea until days later. Because of that headline-making incident, you may have forgotten that the night's host was none other than Andy Samberg. Yes, before he left SNL and won a Golden Globe for Brooklyn Nine-Nine, Andy hosted the MTV Movie Awards. His 2009 gig was full of Lonely Island songs and re-creations of his SNL digital shorts, including "D*ck in a Box."
Unlike most of the above stars, you likely remember Aziz Ansari hosting in 2010, Jason Sudeikis in 2011, Russell Brand in 2012, Rebel Wilson in 2013, and last year's host, Conan O'Brien. Be sure to tune in on Sunday to see how Amy Schumer stacks up to the long list of former emcees!