Skip Nav
Budget Tips
The Average Cost of an American Wedding May Surprise You
Budget Tips
28 of the Biggest Money Wasters, According to Real People
Budget Tips
221 Upcycling Ideas That Will Blow Your Mind

Schools Rewarding Students With Money

Your Two Cents: Schools Giving Kids Money For Grades

According to the New York Times, more than 200 New York City public schools have been experimenting with incentives for students and teachers to see if "tangible cash rewards can turn a school around." Specifically, performance and the corresponding rewards are based on standardized test scores. Critics argue that these incentives compromise the way children think about learning — the motivation should be knowledge and self-improvement, not dollars. What do you think?

Source

Around The Web
Join The Conversation
King2623663 King2623663 4 years
I read some of the posts and disagree with most of them. Why shoud'nt students be rewarded with money for good grades? The capatilist system is based an being rewarded for hard work so this gets the studenst to see first hand what working harder gets them. Some have said learning should be fun, but d you remember sitting in those tiny seats and having a lot offun, probally not.  
Captious Captious 7 years
This is just part of how backwards the whole system is. REAL learning is fun. Fun doesn't require rewards. Abolish the school districts. Bing on the unschooling!
refinnej refinnej 8 years
this isn't a good thing. shouldn't the motivation be that doing well in school leads to a good college and a well-paying job??? my daughter is in 6th grade and has worked hard to maintain an A average in all subjects since the 1st grade. she already knows that doing well now leads to her first choice college and eventually the job that will allow her to afford jimmy choo shoes all on her own. where is this money going to come from? taxes??? the schools don't receive enough money as it is. we need to get rid of this sense of entitlement. work for the grades because it will help you later in life and not for the quick buck now. besides it is completely unfair to those who do the work (in school) without that financial incentive. and will the top grade earners also receive the money??? to do otherwise would be utterly unfair.
rosey rosey 8 years
I think it's ridiculous to pay kids to make good grades, but I don't think it's a matter of ethics. Shouldn't the school systems pay for better teachers and better materials than giving the kids money for passing arbitrary standardize tests--granted the entire education system is messed up with standardize testing. I made A's all through my education before college and money certainly wasn't an incentive--my parents' expectations where what motivated me, even if I had a good report card, I never got paid for it. I think the schools paying for good grades sends a wrong message.
ElenaEv ElenaEv 8 years
Good points MandyJoBo and jeniferanne. I believe that one of the reasons that kids go to school is to get a degree in order to have a descent career in the future. Otherwise education could be acquired in many wonderful ways (university of life, self study, etc). So why not giving one glimpse of the future to the kids of what is going to come?
leeluvfashion leeluvfashion 8 years
I disagree with this; Kids should not be paid to get good grades. This just teaches children that money is everything. Kids should be taught that learning is something free and that it's not a job.
highclassjunkie highclassjunkie 8 years
this just reinforces a basic value in western (capitalist) civilization. Everything we do is for money, and kids are learning that sooner each generation that passes. Learning is a rewarding experience in itself, which leads to greater oppurtunities later in life. Now it seems that even education has a price... assigned value. So sad.
Silverlining10 Silverlining10 8 years
Plus, kids receive monetary incentives all the time...That's what chores and allowances are. It's nothing new or unethical.
Silverlining10 Silverlining10 8 years
Well, getting good grades is so one can make more money in the future, anyway. There are significant differences between the income of high school graduates and college graduates. So, anything to get kids hitting the books and studying is good, and it's not like kids don't already know that a better future entails more money.
dior_show dior_show 8 years
If you go out of state you get $1250 total
dior_show dior_show 8 years
The state I live in gives rewards for standardized tests in high school. If you pass 3 out of the 4 sections you receive $2500. However, in order to get the full money you need to go to a in-state university for 4 years (basically you get a check for $750 a year). So not only does it encourage students to do well on the test, but also to go to college. I don't see any problem with this system at all, it gives the students incentive to do well, but it also reflects better on the school. Before this system was introduced people used to just go through the tests and not try, which caused certain schools to not get the funding they deserved from the state. It is a pretty fair system, and there certainly are arguments to why it fails, but overall it is agreed that it is a positive part of the education system.
juicylove juicylove 8 years
kind of silly, isnt that basically what scholarships are? you get good grades, and you get money. although its money for school, but still. i dont think its neccessary for elementary level kids though, theyre so young, they shouldnt be bribed to do well, they should be told the benefits of doing well and motivated by things other than money.
NHPOD NHPOD 8 years
Kids at our district don't take standardized tests seriously because they know it "doesn't count." They already are entitled...the whole "if I'm not getting anything from the effort, I'm not going to do it" attitude is prevalent. It would be nice if kids had a love of learning and would put pride into everything they tried, but in reality, this isn't happening. Which is worse...giving into this entitlement belief and paying them for a job well done or holding the line and then trying to defend low test scores to the community in shock? I don't like the idea. But I dislike more how little education matters to this country and its kids.
tee0206 tee0206 8 years
Sure; turn them all into capitalist bastards early on. I jest. It just seems like such a waste of money to me.
maybeimnot maybeimnot 8 years
As a teacher in a title I school.... all this does is add to their already-too-high sense of entitlement - causing bigger problems in the future. A lot of these kids won't continue in school anyway- and what happens when the next school doesn't pay -and kids go 'well what do I get if I do it?" "knowledge" ... doesn't matter to them. Making learning interesting and having learning reward them, and teaching them not to give up, hard work, etc... THAT helps.
tiff58 tiff58 8 years
I think this is a ridiculous idea. I never got money for my good grades in school, yet I continued to do very well- because I knew why I had to do well for my future. Maybe schools should spent their money teaching children about how these grades will help them to excel in life.
ilanac13 ilanac13 8 years
i don't really see any problems with doing this - but then again it may not be the best thing. i wish that there was a way for kids to stay motivated and learn but sometimes especially with the way the world is - giving $$ isn't a bad thing...
princessjaslew princessjaslew 8 years
I don't see any problems with it as long as ALL the children are given a fair chance to get this reward. Regardless of whether its cold hard cash or its candy or tickets to a movie, its a reward for a job well done. That in itself is a lesson the kids are learning. Keeping promises. THat's a whole other matter. Telling kids they are going to get a reward for a job well done and then not fulfilling that promise can only spell trouble.
popgoestheworld popgoestheworld 8 years
How is this unethical?
snowbunny11 snowbunny11 8 years
Le Luxe- money is the reward for good work done when kids grow up. Adults are paid on a merit system, so I don't see what this teaches kids that isn't true in the real world. If my boss stamps a "Good job!!!" on my paycheck instead of a dollar amount, there will be trouble. I remember when I was little, Book-it was very popular, and though I would have read anyway, it felt nice (though unhealthy!!) to get a tangible reward. I know that intrinsic motivation is all the rage in educator training right now, but maybe it just doesn't make sense. While I would only work at a job that I felt good about, and I am proud of my work, extrinsic motivation is a realistic part of life. I never got paid for grades when I was in school, even though I got straight A's, and I think that taxpayer's money should not go towards paying kids to do well in school, however I don't think the idea is all that crazy. What will you teach kids? That doing your work well pays in addition to teaching you and being a good experience.
DesignRchic DesignRchic 8 years
I think it's ridiculous to reward kids with money for something they're suppose to do.
sundrops sundrops 8 years
My parents used to pay me for my grades. It worked for me - I heart being a straight a student (and still do). Now as to that translating into actually DOING something better with my life later on down the road, I'm not sure it had any effect. More encouragement to go to college before I got married and had kids might've been better. The monetary motivation did help me to strive for good grades and be genuinely happy when I received them though!
sunnyheart sunnyheart 8 years
Ask any professional educator (like me) and yes, it really is that different from giving scholarships! Academic research proves the more external rewards you give to young children, the less they are internally motivated to learn anything just for the sheer joy of learning. The younger you start extrinsic rewards, the worse it gets (those college students who get scholarships already have a love of learning). This idea makes me shudder--it is so wrong in so many ways!
erinsugar erinsugar 8 years
I think it's a bad idea, but is it really that different from giving scholarships to those who do well academically? If they're going to give it away the money should be given in the form of an education grant.
Nicknames For Grandma in Spanish
Backyard Camping With Kids
How Your Life Changes After a Second Kid
Raising Kids In a Hateful World
Marriage Problems After Having Kids
Toddler With Cancer Has Bucket List (Video)
Fourth of July Punch Drink Recipe

POPSUGAR, the #1 independent media and technology company for women. Where more than 75 million women go for original, inspirational content that feeds their passions and interests.

From Our Partners
Latest Career & Money
X