Yes, but not because of that Robert Pattinson dude who's totally unappealing and always looks unwashed. Jon Hamm and George Clooney are a billion times more sexy than Johnny Depp. He's cute but uber hot? I don't think so.

I think he deserves it but it is just a little random that it would be this year. I mean, I feel like he was barely around. People magazine has bad timing, I think.

Before I even scrolled down, I knew that the "yes" option in the poll was going to mention Robert Pattinson. Sigh.

I agree that Jon Hamm would've been a great choice.

yes, i thought jennifer aniston was going to be sma

I think Johnny is sexy as hell and gets better as the years go on...love this choice. I think I would have thrown up if it had gone to Robert Pattinson - seriously he needs to take a shower.

Jon Hamm should have been on the cover

I was surprised because People tends to pander to soccer moms in middle America. Don't they all love Robert Pattinson this year?

He was barely around??? Did you miss the media blitz that was Public Enemies? He was EVERYWHERE! Not that I'm complaining. =)

Surprised but not disappointed.

I think there are quite a few men who deserve that award, but Johnny Depp is among them. He's not really my type, but he's a handsome man when he's cleaned up.

johnny depp doesnt have sex appeal. he has a pretty face but thats about it. robert pattinson has a pretty face plus tons of charm to back it up. johnny depp is just weird. nice to know that the term 'sexy' is directed only towards looks now. i personally thought it was supposed to be an all encompassing term that was centered on a lot of things; not just peoples appearance.

oh please robert pattinson hasn't done enough to deserve the honor. I was surprised but certainly not disappointed

no, not surprised that Johnny Depp has made the list again.. but I'm SOOOO disappointed that John Hamm isn't on there!!! Don Draper should have at least made the list!!!!

Rob has been around enough or even old enough to make this title- I do think he is the Sexy and the best in my book.
I think Johnny Depp is a good choice but what suprises me is that he hasn't really had anything big out in the past year and he just got this same title back on 2003.
I would think someone who had a big year would have been named.

Johnny Depp is ridiculously appealing in so many ways - he's physically attractive, has a great personality, and is an amazing actor. Robert Pattinson, really?

I meant to has Rob hasn't been around enough not has been- sorry.

...I'd even take Johnny as Edward Scissorhands over most hollywood dudes...

Johnny Depp (rolls tongue....) He's been a little bit off the radar, but then that's his style isn't it? He's gorgeous. Quirky, talented, unassuming, fabulously rich, faithful to his wife/girlfriend....

I am just glad it wasn't Pattinson, finally a poll where the twicrazies wasn't allow to vote lol and plus he hasn't done anything to deserve that title and he is not quite a man yet imo

surprised but not dispointed.

sexy as hell!

Johnny Depp has a big movie coming out in a couple of months (Alice in Wonderland). No surprise here.

Depp is the ORIGINAL...sorry R.Patts, ur gonna have to earn your stripes with more than a couple Vampire movies!!

I LOVE HIM !!! He is so sexy and such a great actor !!!
Robert Pattinson has a lot of press...but is not sexy at all !!!

Johnny Depp needs a bath! I can't get past the thought that his hair stinks.

Johnny should win every year! Rob- who?

HE'S SOOOO HOTTT

I love Johnny, but it seems like kind of a random year for it. Like others, I was expecting Jon Hamm.

It's a choice that seemed rather out of the blue since he's been so low key lately... but then again it's Johnny.

Suprised? Yes but in a good way! I've always loved him. I'm just suprised he wasn't beaten out by the younger crowd. Not that I don't like em'. Good choice people!

When isn't he the sexiest man alive?

johnny !!!

Robert Pattinson is a little women, but Johnny is soooooooooo hot. He definitely deserves the honor {}{}{}

i'm surprised just b/c he has been pretty low key since the last of the Pirates movies, so he's kind of a random choice...still happy about it though! he actually deserves the title

I'm only surprised that People had the good taste of naming him instead of Pattinson, the man with a concave profile.

Johnny Depp is not only the sexiest man alive, he's also the best actor in the world and an extremely kind human being.

Rob hasn't been around long enough to get this honor and once the twilight series is over with, it will be interesting to see if he will still have staying power. He's not cute at all to me, but I'm not a tween. Johnny deserves it, but I would have given it to him a while ago. Who is Jon Hamm?

Bad choice in my book and not because it wasn't Rob either.

he looks homeless.ick

good choice! I'm not surprised, I saw Johnny in Venezia two years ago, he's really beautiful, carismatic, sexy, hot, fantastic! and second the irresistible Robert Downey jr, not the insignificant Pattinson!

Hey POP SUGAR ,I WANT TO SEE THE RESULTS!!!JOHNNY ALLLLLLLLLL THE WAY!!!HE IS GORGEOUS!!!NO BODY CAN COMPITE WITH HIM,HE IS UNIQUE,I LOVE HIM,. rob is only young and popular ,and he has a lot of publicity nothing more. JOHNNY IS GOOD ACTOR AND BEAUTIFULL;God bless him