Skip Nav
Beauty Tips
The 1 Thing You Should Never Say to a Woman Over 30
Why This 1 Makeup Artist Says, "Please Stop Asking Me For Kardashian Eyebrows"
Beauty News
This New Too Faced Palette Will "Revolutionize Your Glitterization"

Beauty Mark It Results: Eyeliner

You probably know that Cleopatra was a big fan of the heavy-handed dark eyeliner, and with Halloween looming right around the corner, now’s a perfect time to do a little experimenting with eye makeup yourself. How bold will you go?

For last week’s Beauty Mark It challenge, I asked you to share your opinions about eyeliner. Whether it be a pencil, liquid, or gel formulation — what's your take? Thanks to all who took the time to add to our ever-expanding Product Reviews site. I'm highlighting a few of my favorites below, and don't forget to enter for a chance to win Bella's Ultimate Beauty Getaway in San Francisco. Take it away, steen:

  • Steen reviewed CoverGirl Perfect Point Plus Self Sharpening Eye Pencil ($4.99) —
    "It's no lie that I absolutely LOVE Blacktrack Fluidline by MAC ($15) for a crisp cat eye. But when I want a softer look, I won't use anything but the Perfect Point pencil. I have this pencil in three different colors and have yet to find anything better. The smudge tip is very handy . . . and the liner stays put throughout the day. What more could you need? A huge bonus for me is that I can easily go to any drugstore and pick it up."
See the rest of the reviews when you


  • Gabiushka reviewed Maybelline Expert Eyes Twin Brow & Eye Pencils ($3.49) — "Great texture that is soft on the delicate skin around the eyes but feels firm on the pencil and manages to stay wherever it is that you want it! I have been using this for years in its brown color and always end with an effortlessly natural look."
  • ElisabethR reviewed Laura Mercier Eye Pencil ($19): "Laura Mercier's eyeliner is soft, and the color is intense. My favorite is her Wild Violet — it looks so fabulous on my blue eyes, and adds a perfect touch to a purple smoky eye!"
Around The Web
Join The Conversation
nashiyah nashiyah 8 years
I love kate(Japan brand) it's gel liner
bacon1 bacon1 8 years
I never wear eyeliner, I'm too scared of it. It always looks horrible on me. I wish eyeliner was wayyy easier.
fleurdelispink fleurdelispink 8 years
I like Rimmel's Eye Twist, which gives a cream shadow on one side, and a color-coordinated liner on the other. I have them in shades of brown/copper (Two's Company), black/silver (Two Timer), and purple/pink (Double Trouble). SO easy to put on!
graylen graylen 8 years
I'm still head over heels for Clinique's Brush-On Cream Liner is Deep Brown. I love it even more at the end of the day when it still looks perfect!
emalove emalove 8 years
I'd love to try the Laura Mercier one--I love her products and purple is my color when it comes to eye makeup.
katykat katykat 8 years
My favorite eyeliner right now is Physician's Formula loose khol powder. I put it on somewhat heavy and then clean away most of it. It stays put forever and looks great and surprisingly not too made up.
Beauty Mark It Results: Luscious Lip Plumpers
Beauty Mark It Results:  Fragrances Under $25
Beauty Mark It Results: Hair Removal
Beauty Mark It Results: Foundation
Beauty Mark It Results: Beautiful Body Scrubs
Beauty Mark It Results:  Growing the Hair Out Gracefully
Beauty Mark It Results:  An "Un" Beauty Vacation

POPSUGAR, the #1 independent media and technology company for women. Where more than 75 million women go for original, inspirational content that feeds their passions and interests.

From Our Partners
Latest Beauty
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds