Skip Nav
Beauty News
Kat Von D Reveals Her Own Saint + Sinner Beauty Secrets
Beauty Trends
ColourPop's Newest Collection Will Rock Your Crystal-Centric World
Beauty Sales
Now Is the Time to Treat Yourself to This Sweet Kat Von D Rock Candy Set

Best of 2007: Eye Shadow

I'm embarrassed to admit how many different eye shadows I have. Even though I usually wear the same base color each day, there's part of me that thinks, "Well, I might need this glittery turquoise color someday! I'd better keep it."

I definitely have my favorite brands of eye shadow, and I bet you do, too. Vote for your go-to shadow now, and I'll share the winners — yours and mine—in a couple of weeks. Missed a poll? It's not too late to vote in the Sugar Awards!

Join The Conversation
trixxi1 trixxi1 9 years
I love the creaseless cream eyeshadows from Benefit.
vcarlton vcarlton 9 years
Bobbi Brown, MAC, and Stila (for Kitten and Twig)
phree2b phree2b 9 years
revlon colorstay is inexpensive and stays..
anakiya anakiya 9 years
I don't normally wear shadow. I guess I just never learned to apply it.
Spree Spree 9 years
janeyates janeyates 9 years
love it
mwoodard mwoodard 9 years
LORAC or Lancome
the-makeup-blogette the-makeup-blogette 9 years
diamondgirl204 diamondgirl204 9 years
I love love love MAC shadows!!! but for the price loreal hip pigments are damn good, especially if you use a good primer first underneath. i prefer Mac shadesticks for that
katielisa777 katielisa777 9 years
Glow Minerals!!!! Its the best. I've used a TON of mineral makeup (yes including bare escentuals) and this is my fave!
Pretty_Kitty07 Pretty_Kitty07 9 years
I like Almay, their eye color inhancing eyeshadows are amazing!
ricarocks ricarocks 9 years
i love mac's colours but the eyeshadow itself is pretty average. doesn't blend, fades throughout the day... although i will give credits to it because it doesn't collect in the crease of the eye :)
marthalilian126 marthalilian126 9 years
I'm definitely a fan of my BareMinerals products -- but for the price Elf can not be beat!
I-freaking-rock I-freaking-rock 9 years
MAC! But I think HIP is an awesome drugstore alternative.
kristya kristya 9 years
MAC! That or Urban Decay.
mmechou mmechou 9 years
Maybelline Dream Mousse Shadow
chills chills 9 years
MAC may be really cool, but Bare Essentials is the only thing I have found that does not crease on my eye lids.
judeandam judeandam 9 years
For me, it's a toss up between my Mac and Ulta brand shadows. They both are pretty true to color and wear really well. My L'oreal HIP shadows are pretty good quality for their cost. They are highly pigmented like advertised and I love the bold colors that are available. The Max Factor MaxEye shadows I've gotten are pretty disappointing. They're super sheer when applied dry and the shadow cake is harder than most. But then again, they're only $3 each so I guess you get what you pay for.
lollidolli007 lollidolli007 9 years
Urban Decay (plus they have a amazing selection) and Yves Saint Laurent is really great too or Guerlain terracotta loose powder kohl eyeliner has rich pigment I haven't tried the eye shadows, but I imagine they'd be good too. I'm not huge on eyeshadow though thats neon or bright I like my colors really dark deep, but still look rich so the eyes pop. Also not to much eyeshadow or any sort of make up. It should enhance your natural beauty and features. When people wear to much eyeshadow it looks really trashy or silly.
KrazeeCourtney08 KrazeeCourtney08 9 years
I <3 AvOn Eyeshadow!
rachi99 rachi99 9 years
Urban Decay, altho' I also love my Nars, Mac, and Stila. Still, I end up wearing UD about 4-5 days a week. There's a tremendous range of colors and textures, they are well pigmented, and provide good staying power.
Ainsleec04 Ainsleec04 9 years
I used to be drawn to MAC b/c of their pigmentation, but I found that NARS are just as highly pigmented and crease less than MAC. I'm converting...
lily8206 lily8206 9 years
I love MAC. Everytime I go in to the store it's impossible not to buy another eyeshadow - their colour selection is fantastic!
motherof3 motherof3 9 years
Other... Urban Decay
ElissaM ElissaM 9 years
Bare Minerals for sure!
From Our Partners
Latest Beauty
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds