We've all had days where eyeliner has been the bane of our makeup existence. Whether you're a liner rookie or a cat-eye pro [1], picking the perfect liner can be a challenge. After sorting through various formulas, colors, and finishes, how do you know which liner is best? We've tested and selected these stellar yet budget-friendly liners [2] that rival their high-end counterparts.
E.L.F. Intense H20 Proof Eyeliner Pen
Smudges be gone with this H2O-proof [3] ($6) liner! The pen applicator is makes this liquid liner a breeze to apply.
Maybelline Lasting Drama Light Eyeliner
The Lasting Drama Light [3] ($6) brightens and illuminates eyes with a hint of shimmer.
Hard Candy Stroke of Gorgeous
Stroke of Gorgeous [4] ($5) pencils come in four finishes: Creamy Matte, Chrome, High Intensity Brights, and Glitter. Each finish glides on oh so smoothly.
Wet N Wild MegaSlim Skinny Tip Eyeliner
No-makeup makeup days just got easier with this MegaSlim Skinny Tip Liner [5] ($5).
Pixi Eye Define Waterline
The ultraslim tip on the Eye Define Waterline [6] ($14) is the answer to defined liner sans the tears.
Flower Vinyl-Eyes Glossy Gel
If you prefer a liner with sheen, the Vinyl-Eyes Glossy Gel [7] ($8) is for you. Its high-shine finish adds boldness to even the simplest of looks.
Physicians Formula Eye Booster Matte Lacquer Cream
There's so much to love in the Eye Booster Matte Lacquer Cream Eyeliner [8] ($8). The twist pen applicator makes perfecting gel liner a breeze and the matte finish adds a subtle edge to any look.
Soap & Glory Supercat Skinny Precision Eyeliner
Create uberthin lines with this Supercat Skinny Precision Eyeliner [9] ($10). Use it to rim your cat eye or create a barely there look.
Revlon ColorStay Exactify Liquid Liner
If liquid liner seems nigh impossible for you, this wheel-tip applicator was made for you! The ColorStay Exactify Liquid [10] ($12) allows for precise lines, even with a shaky hand.
CoverGirl truNAKED Waterproof Eyeliner Duo
The truNAKED Waterproof [11] ($5) duos feature a dual tip to create blended color looks in a breeze.
NYX Put a Wing on It
When you want to go there with your liner, Put a Wing on It [12] ($10) marker-like felt tip liner creates bold, graphic lines in a pinch.
