Skip Nav
Celebrity Makeup
Proof This Single Makeup Product Can Change Your Entire Beauty Look
Beauty News
Your Favorite Kat Von D Lipsticks Are Discounted For 1 Day Only
Beauty News
You Can Get a Free MAC Lipstick — but Only For 1 Day

Fantastic Felt-Tip Eyeliner Pens, Part II: Waterproof Eyeliner

Welcome back to part two of Fantastic Felt-Tip Eyeliner Pens. In part one, we saw a mix of designer and drugstore brands. Today we take a peek at a couple of waterproof eyeliner pens.

LORAC Front Of The Line Waterproof Eyeliner ($20) is a waterproof and smudge-proof liquid eyeliner pen. This easy-to-use pen, which is more like a magic marker for your eyes, makes precision a cinch. Just draw a thin line for a classical seductress look, or a thick line for a more dramatic rocker type of eye. It is available in black, brown and dark green.

For one more waterproof felt-tip eyeliner pen,

Physicians Formula Eye Definer ($6.95) is a felt-tip eyeliner that glides on super smooth without any skipping or slipping. This pen has a little bit of a bigger tip to create a heavier line. I can't say for sure that it's 100% waterproof (I think it's more water-resistant) but it stays on for 24 hours and doesn't smear. It's also hypoallergenic and fragrance-free. It is available in ultra black, warm black and dark brown.

Join The Conversation
brandi797 brandi797 9 years
I bought the Phys Formula eye definer...it really sucked. The eyeliner did not flow from the tip at all--it was very dry and impossible to make a nice line. Trash!
sioux5ita sioux5ita 9 years
I bought the Physicians Formula Eye Definer from Target and I HATE it. It doesn't work on me at all and so it's going in the trash. I'm glad it was only $7 and not $20.
cwjam88 cwjam88 9 years
So if oil based makeup remover removes waterproof eyeliner..then someone with oily skin shouldn't use this because it will smudge?
indielove indielove 9 years
Vaseline removes waterproof makeup. I know some people are iffy about using Vaseline for beauty regimes and such, but it does the trick in removing waterproof ANYTHING. anyway, i think i'm going to check out the Physician's Formula one.
marley11 marley11 9 years
wow, good idea!
glamorouswink glamorouswink 9 years
Do they both work the same> or is the lorac one better?
quietone84 quietone84 9 years
The Lorace in green is going on my Sephora wishlist! I've always wanted a colored eyeliner & waterproof seems to be a must for me.
fablavishlife fablavishlife 9 years
I want the Physicians Formula felt tip eyeliner!
sillyfilly sillyfilly 9 years
I bought the Lorac Dark Green! I really like it thus far - gotta get used to it but it is cool. :)
vienvien vienvien 9 years
WAterproof eyeliners and mascras are a no-no for me. They're a pain to remove
catstarr catstarr 9 years
I love the physician formula felt tip eyeliner. Its the only liquid eyeliner I can use!
Feesje Feesje 9 years
I use an oil-based remover for my waterproof mascara. Works perfectly.
demonkitty18 demonkitty18 9 years
well, mine is.
makicabrera10 makicabrera10 9 years
is waterproof eyeliner/mascara harder to remove?
Nikkie Tutorials Wonder Woman Makeup Tutorial
How to Apply a Cat Eye With a Tweezer
Maisie Williams Hair and Makeup at the SAG Awards 2017
Lorac Pirates of the Caribbean Collection
From Our Partners
Latest Beauty
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds