Skip Nav
Yes, Fenty Beauty Is Cruelty-Free — Because Rihanna F*cking Gets It
Beauty Tips
Why Expecting Women Should Make This 1 Major Beauty Change For a Toxic-Free Pregnancy
Guess Who's Back? Get Your Hands On This Sold-Out Kat Von D Eye Shadow

Fantastic Felt-Tip Eyeliner Pens, Part II: Waterproof Eyeliner

Welcome back to part two of Fantastic Felt-Tip Eyeliner Pens. In part one, we saw a mix of designer and drugstore brands. Today we take a peek at a couple of waterproof eyeliner pens.

LORAC Front Of The Line Waterproof Eyeliner ($20) is a waterproof and smudge-proof liquid eyeliner pen. This easy-to-use pen, which is more like a magic marker for your eyes, makes precision a cinch. Just draw a thin line for a classical seductress look, or a thick line for a more dramatic rocker type of eye. It is available in black, brown and dark green.

For one more waterproof felt-tip eyeliner pen,

Physicians Formula Eye Definer ($6.95) is a felt-tip eyeliner that glides on super smooth without any skipping or slipping. This pen has a little bit of a bigger tip to create a heavier line. I can't say for sure that it's 100% waterproof (I think it's more water-resistant) but it stays on for 24 hours and doesn't smear. It's also hypoallergenic and fragrance-free. It is available in ultra black, warm black and dark brown.

Join The Conversation
brandi797 brandi797 10 years
I bought the Phys Formula eye really sucked. The eyeliner did not flow from the tip at all--it was very dry and impossible to make a nice line. Trash!
sioux5ita sioux5ita 10 years
I bought the Physicians Formula Eye Definer from Target and I HATE it. It doesn't work on me at all and so it's going in the trash. I'm glad it was only $7 and not $20.
cwjam88 cwjam88 10 years
So if oil based makeup remover removes waterproof eyeliner..then someone with oily skin shouldn't use this because it will smudge?
indielove indielove 10 years
Vaseline removes waterproof makeup. I know some people are iffy about using Vaseline for beauty regimes and such, but it does the trick in removing waterproof ANYTHING. anyway, i think i'm going to check out the Physician's Formula one.
marley11 marley11 10 years
wow, good idea!
glamorouswink glamorouswink 10 years
Do they both work the same> or is the lorac one better?
quietone84 quietone84 10 years
The Lorace in green is going on my Sephora wishlist! I've always wanted a colored eyeliner & waterproof seems to be a must for me.
fablavishlife fablavishlife 10 years
I want the Physicians Formula felt tip eyeliner!
sillyfilly sillyfilly 10 years
I bought the Lorac Dark Green! I really like it thus far - gotta get used to it but it is cool. :)
vienvien vienvien 10 years
WAterproof eyeliners and mascras are a no-no for me. They're a pain to remove
catstarr catstarr 10 years
I love the physician formula felt tip eyeliner. Its the only liquid eyeliner I can use!
Feesje Feesje 10 years
I use an oil-based remover for my waterproof mascara. Works perfectly.
demonkitty18 demonkitty18 10 years
well, mine is.
makicabrera10 makicabrera10 10 years
is waterproof eyeliner/mascara harder to remove?
Lorac Pro Palette Giveaway
Where to Buy the Lorac Mega Pro 4 Palette
Lorac Beauties Who Brunch Collection
Lorac Unzipped Sunset Palettes
From Our Partners
Latest Beauty
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds