In the wish list of eyeliner capabilities, if it's long lasting, glides on with velvety smoothness, and is easy to smudge without actually looking smudgy, then that's one amazing product. Such is the case with the Victoria's Secret VS Makeup Eyeliner ($12), particularly in Black Velvet. Its creamy texture makes it almost foolproof to apply, and thanks to a built-in smudger tip, you can fix mistakes and create smoky effects Victoria's Secret-runway-style just like a pro. Bonus points for its wearability factor, too. This richly pigmented liner lasts all day, even after a mile-long walk in the drizzling rain.