Jake Gyllenhaal knows how to make a birthday girl feel special! We've seen our winner travel to LA, get put up in style, and undergo her amazing makeover — now it's time for her big moment with Jake on the finale of I'm a Huge Fan! Amanda started feeling butterflies as she entered the theater to meet Jake, but he instantly put her at ease with his smile and adorable sense of humor. She sat down for a one-on-one interview where he touted his singing skills — though he doesn't have a go-to Karaoke song — revealed how much he loved the kissing scene, and said it was harder to maintain his hair than his muscles. Next, the two headed down to present Prince of Persia to the crowd of Sugar readers. Jake once again pulled out the charm, presenting Amanda with a birthday cake and leading a rendition of "Happy Birthday." As he left, he ran back in to tease us one more time about taking off his shirt, but in the end you're just going to have to see Prince of Persia for that. As Jake says, "any good woman needs to be wooed," and he certainly captured our hearts throughout I'm a Huge Fan! — enjoy!

In case you missed parts one and two — the big reveal and the makeover — watch them when you