Skip Nav
9 Summer Makeup Palettes You Can Get at Sephora — All Under $50
Beauty News
Here's a Sneak Peek at Maybelline's Upcoming Wonder Woman Makeup Collection!
The Key to Passing a Physics Exam? Hiding the Formulas Under Your Nails, Apparently

Love It or Hate It? Guyliner

Fall Out Boy bassist Pete Wentz is known for his pop hooks and good looks—and for wearing eyeliner, too (all right, and for dating Ashlee Simpson). My friends and I disagree over whether men look cheesy or hot when they wear makeup. So I want to know what you think: Does guyliner work, or is it corny?


Join The Conversation
phree2b phree2b 9 years
Hey Julie2812! In the photo, if that is you, It's Super cute, You look like a girl on Ebay that makes headbands named Mixedbaby, I think from Texas, Can't really remember but I thought she was Really pretty too!
Spree Spree 9 years
it annoys me...
keiraz keiraz 9 years
so gay and unmanly
mizlynz mizlynz 9 years
I think it works for some guys if they don't totally put it on overkill like Pete. I don't HATE guyliner.
potterlove potterlove 9 years
My hate for guyliner is beyond explanation! I'm sorry Pete!! I totally LOVE you, but lose the liner! It just doesn't work for ANYONE! You pull it off fine, but still. NO!!!
krystalmak krystalmak 9 years
Very very not hot. I don't wear makeup.. If a guy wears more make up than I do, does that make him more feminine? I don't like the guyliner
fablavishlife fablavishlife 9 years
Depends how much is put on. It looks fine on Pete Wentz sometimes, I think hes adorable most of the time.
fobbfskcp fobbfskcp 9 years
I love it! Guy liner is hot on Pete
bringmeup bringmeup 9 years
Doesn't look bad on Johnny Depp that's for sure!
floweroflove floweroflove 9 years
i like guyliner but not on pete wentz, i don't think he's pretty.
BlackCatMusely BlackCatMusely 9 years
first i'd like to make it clear: I HATE GUYLINER WITH ALL THE PASSION I COULD POSSIBLEY MUSTER , but com'on: a picture of pete wentz? he looks bad without it
tysontysonxv tysontysonxv 9 years
I have to admit, as much of a purist as I am, some guys kinda look good in eyeliner. It's not my style, but if a guy can rock it, so be it.
TiffanyNicole TiffanyNicole 9 years
Usually I would have to say neigh to this madness but, honestly I think it depends on the guy. Not on my guy (if I had one) but, on the rocker type I think it goes with the whole 80's Rock Revival that is going on right now!
redhead redhead 9 years
depends on the guy...on Peter- it works.
catpoetess catpoetess 9 years
I don't like the guy-liner on this guy in particular. But Ozzy has always looked pretty cool wearing it. And shoot, Johnny Depp is downright YUMMY (whether he wears it or not).
ModernGraceKelly ModernGraceKelly 9 years
Isn't everything now coming back "new", when it's really been done before.
marykatherineq marykatherineq 9 years
Men with makeup are creeeeeeepy...
ailene ailene 9 years
Only certain guys can pull off "guyliner." Chris Daughtry pulls it off really well. He's wearing it in the main photo of his official website:
conanho conanho 9 years
i'm from chicago and was once hit on by mr. guy-liner himself...i must say, the guy-liner had nothing to do with my decision not to play along.
peachiepink peachiepink 9 years
this look is VERY rarely hot, and he is not one of those rare men.
dead_vanity dead_vanity 9 years
the guys who rock eyeliner are the ones who don't give a shit if other people like it or not. But staying on topic, I think it's hot if on a guy with a nice face to begin with, for example Gerard Way. Pete, however, has an ogrish face and therefore eyeliner does nothing but make him look like shrek in drag. and please let's not call guyliner "punk". glam-rock? yes. punk? don't make me start on the rules of punk. thank you :]
MandyJoBo MandyJoBo 9 years
I like it, but it's not exactly professional. I can't see a successful man other than an artist pulling this off. So in general, it's a no.
Tamma1387 Tamma1387 9 years
Only if they put it on right. Pete needs to learn the term "everything in moderation", he does not need to put an extra layer of eyeliner on everytime on of their songs are played.
How to Apply a Cat Eye Using a Bobby Pin
Tarte Sex Kitten Eyeliner
How to Apply a Cat Eye With a Tweezer
Holographic Eyeliner Ideas
From Our Partners
Latest Beauty
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds