Okay, I have to be honest with all of you: I looked at Mel B. and thought, "Wow, she looks amazing! Eddie Murphy must feel like such a cad for treating her so rudely." The best revenge is looking great, they say, and Mel's big smile shows that she's living it up.

But then I looked closer, and saw visible lip liner. Gah! Melanie Brown, you know better! Still, we all make a makeup faux pas now and then (remember Paris' lipsticky teeth?), and overall, this Spice is far from scary. What do you think?