Unlike her older sister, Paris, Nicky Hilton somehow manages to stay just under the radar. But tonight, should all the attention go to the younger sister? While Nicky keeps it pretty tame with a fruity-toned lip gloss, she amps up those vivid baby blues with lots of black liner for a tightly lined eye look. To further accentuate her peepers, she opts for gold shadows with a sparkling copper shade in the crease. Are you dazzled by Nicky's look, or did she play it just a little too safe tonight?

Vote on all of my MTV VMAs polls here!