Skip Nav
What ALL 40 Shades of Rihanna's Fenty Beauty Foundation Really Look Like
Beauty Trends
Mario Dedivanovic Wants You to Use $11 Jelly on Your Face For the Perfect Highlight
Holiday Beauty
11 Natural Beauty Gifts That Prove Whole Foods Is Great for Holiday Shopping

Product Review: Stila Convertible Eye Color

As soon as I laid my eyes on this Stila Convertible Eye Color ($20), I knew it was special. Not only do I appreciate the value of a two-in-one product (and in this case, a three-in-one product), but it also takes the guesswork out of coordinating your eye-makeup colors. One side of the wand contains a pencil eyeliner, the middle section unscrews to reveal a shimmery powder eye shadow (in the same color family), and at the other end is a plush smudging tip. In a nutshell, it's fast, fabulous, and fool-proof.

The pigment in the eyeliner is rich, dark, long lasting, and the eye shadow blends easily. It's perfect for your pocketbook or for travel because you don't even need to use a brush — it comes with a ready-to-use compact applicator tip.

The darker colors create an easy-to-achieve smoky eye and the lighter colors are a great way to add a sexy touch of twinkle. That being said, the one minor downfall is that you really have to scrub to get the liner to come off. Even when I used makeup remover, I could still see traces of eyeliner under my eyes.

Stila Convertible Eye Color is available in 12 beautiful shades. If you're interested in seeing a few of the colors up close,





See reader reviews of this product and add your own here!

redsilkshoes redsilkshoes 9 years
I've had these since they first came out and honestly, they're on my list of WORST Stila products ever. Give me the Smudgepots anytime. (wearing Bronze today)
smiley13tree smiley13tree 9 years
i want to try it!
running-home running-home 9 years
I have the brownish-silver one and I loooooove it. They're great to stash at the BF's place because he has very little space for me to keep things, especially beauty products
JaimeLeah526 JaimeLeah526 9 years
I never wear coordinating eyeliner. What's the point? I'd just wear the shadow as liner if I wanted them to be the same.
MrsJigglesworth MrsJigglesworth 9 years
sounds convenient! I must try this.
StefaPie StefaPie 9 years
I've had this eyeliner forever and never knew it had a shadow in it! I feel like I got a free present from them or something. Thanks Bella!
emalove emalove 9 years
This is one of my favorite Stila products! I discovered it a few years ago and I LOVE it. Clinique used to make (they might still, not sure) a similar product and I used it all through high school and college. When I saw this Stila one, I knew I had to have it!!
kayla74 kayla74 9 years
I have two of them! I like to keep them in my purse so I can do a touchup if I'm going out after work.
gigill gigill 9 years
Great travel product!
loveleighdancer loveleighdancer 9 years
I have the green one. It is fabulous!!!!! Definitely a good purchase!
ohsoapplesweet ohsoapplesweet 9 years
Smudges way too easily! definitely need to do major touch ups if you buy this product.
teagirl teagirl 9 years
kahribar kahribar 9 years
I am def going to try this out!
bluesarahlou bluesarahlou 9 years
I have the violet shade...and I love it. My only problem is that sometimes it's hard to get enough shadow onto the sponge thingie (without having to swipe over my eye a bunch of times).
glam-sugar glam-sugar 9 years
That would be great for traveling.
chiquita29 chiquita29 9 years
I can't wait to try this, I use Stilla's convertible lip & cheek color in lillium, and was dissapointed to find that i didn't like the color on my lips at all. I do like it on my cheeks though so that's what I use it for. I love multi tasking beauty products!
marcella marcella 9 years
I have the green one called "ivy". It's gorgeous! Love it!!
MartiniLush MartiniLush 9 years
I will have to try this!
babygal14 babygal14 9 years
rachi99 rachi99 9 years
I had this in a pretty rosy shade, but I had trouble with the eyeliner - it was very soft, so I had difficulty making a precise line, and it very quickly became too broad and smooshed to use at all. Maybe they've changed the formula? I hope so, because I really liked the idea (and adored the color and ease of application of the eyeshadow proper) - just didn't get my money's worth.
NYX Liquid Suede Metallic Lipstick Review
Candy Cane Eyeliner Ideas
Sephora Weekly Wow Sale
Best Dose of Colors Products
From Our Partners
Latest Beauty
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds