I really like fiber mascaras, because they don't smudge and come off so nicely, so I was interested to see what people would have to say about Shu Uemura Fiber Xtension Lengthening Mascara ($23). Reader Georgia S, though, isn't so much, and she has some observations about the product's hypoallergenic claims, too, saying:

This might be a great product if you don't have sensitive eyes, or if you don't wear contact lenses like I do. I have another Shu mascara that I adore, but this is just a mess on me. It stings my eyes and is too clumpy for my taste. Keep in mind, though, that I'm not a fan of fiber mascaras because I end up with spidery eyelashes. If you are a fan, give it a try.

Not loving your latest buy? Want to know what products other people are having trouble with? Head on over to our Product Reviews pages, then, where you can read up on reviews of over 50,000 products, and even write one of your own.