Skip Nav
DIY Beauty
3 Unexpected Ways to Be Wonder Woman For Halloween: Zombie, Cyborg, and Pop Art
Beauty News
These 11 Skincare Sets Under $50 Help You Get Fancy on a Budget
Makeup-Lovers, This Light-Up Mirror on Amazon Prime Is Going Viral — and It's Only $15

Reader Review of the Day: Stila Eyes & Shine Smudge Pot Trio Gel Eyeliner

Reader Review of the Day: Stila Eyes & Shine Smudge Pot Trio Gel Eyeliner

For today's review, let's look at a product by Stila that comes with not just one or two but three of the brand's top-selling smudge pots.

The kit, Stila Eyes & Shine Smudge Pot Trio Gel Eyeliner ($32), contains black, bronze, and gray shades — all must-haves for the ultimate smoky eye. Bella reviewer Scully was a fan, giving the set four out of five stars. And now, take it away, Scully:

"For years I've stayed away from gel/cream eyeliners because my hand is not very steady — boy was I missing out! For me, this was the best purchase I have made lately. You get three colors that are universally flattering and the product stays put. I can apply at 5 a.m. and by 9 p.m. this stuff looks freshly applied and going strong. The texture is creamy and glides on effortlessly. I took one star away only because it is very hard to remove if you make a mistake — but on the flip side — that's why it's so long-lasting. I would recommend this to anyone."

patrigon patrigon 8 years
The bronze and brown colors make great eyeshadows!! I won't wear powder eyeshadow anymore!
JaimeLeah526 JaimeLeah526 8 years
Gorgeous colors. I just bought the loreal HIP gel liners and I loved them.
emalove emalove 8 years
Stila Smudge Pots are FABULOUS. One of the best gel liners I've ever tried. Lasts all day and the color stays true. My favorite is the copper shade, which makes my green eyes stand out.
scully22 scully22 8 years
KadBunny: My lids are very oily too but if I use an eyeshadow primer, it holds the colors and liners intact....
KadBunny KadBunny 8 years
I love my Stila Smudge Pot. :D I don't normally prefer the precise, lined look anyway (except for cat eyes). But I have to disagree with the review; after a few hours it can look smudged and gross. But it's probably just me; my lids tend to get oily. Otherwise I loove.
mnp mnp 8 years
Like kimsy, I use Janes, too. I can't use up any one eyeliner fast enough so I need something cheap that I can toss out after it expires...without cringing. hehe.
kimsy kimsy 8 years
Jane makes a great gel liner as well--as good as any premium brand I've used. It's like $4 at drugstores.
allinavhcnerf allinavhcnerf 8 years
I want to try this! I'm using Prescriptives' Perfect Every Line right now
cupcake_ cupcake_ 8 years
I've wanted to try this for a while now. But like the ladies above me I also use Fluidline:)
glam-sugar glam-sugar 8 years
I love gel liners, I use MAC and Clinique but might buy some Stila next time.
laurenlich laurenlich 8 years
I use mac fluidline too! It stays on ALL day! And so easy to apply!
mondaymoos mondaymoos 8 years
I LOVE gel eyeliners, but I use MAC Fluidline. It's so much easier to make a smooth line than it is with a pencil and they stay so much longer!
Stila Magnificent Metals Liquid Eye Shadow | Summer 2017
Diamond Cat Eye Tutorial
Candy Cane Eyeliner Ideas
Stila Color Balm Color Calm Lipstick
From Our Partners
Latest Beauty
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds