Skip Nav
Beauty Trends
These Are the 10 Most Instagrammable Beauty Trends of Summer 2017
Beauty News
These Color-Changing Unicorn Brushes For Halloween Are "Graveyard Spooktastic"
Beauty News
7 Reddit Hair Hacks That You Haven't Heard Already

Review of Maybelline Expert Eyes Moisturizing Mascara Remover For Waterproof Eye Makeup

Reader Review of the Day: Maybelline Expert Eyes Moisturizing Mascara Remover

I've never tried Maybelline Expert Eyes Moisturizing Mascara Remover for Waterproof Eye Makeup ($5), but I had heard good things about it from a few other people. No product works well for everyone, though, as reader polkadots567's experience with this makeup remover shows. She says:

"I hate this product! I'll admit, I'm sort of a stranger to the whole makeup remover world; this is the first one I've tried and I'm sorely disappointed. I like Maybelline's products, but this one did absolutely nothing to remove eyeliner that wasn't even waterproof in the first place! I had to go back to my standby warm water that I had hoped to give up by now."

Had an unpleasant surprise with your last purchase? Tell us all about it on our Product Reviews pages (your review may even be featured here!). While you're there, make sure to read up on the latest reviews from other readers — there's something new every day.

Join The Conversation
kayleigh83 kayleigh83 7 years
i'm extremely surprised this got a bad review! i'm even wondering if they accidentally reviewed the NON-waterproof version! I use this stuff and it works quite well on my many coats of waterproof mascara!
Akasha Akasha 7 years
I love Cetafil for removing makeup of any kind. It also doesn't leave your skin feeling greasy
Miss-Bree Miss-Bree 7 years
I completely agree. I sacrificed my much-loved Clinique for this trying to save money and I threw this stuff away. It was awful. Great solution: Covergirl makes a $4.00 eye makeup cream remover that works wonders. It's no Clinique, but it's definatly NO Maybelline.
lifelovebeauty lifelovebeauty 7 years
Last time I tried it, this product was really oily and I didn't like that feeling around my eyes. Even after washing my face after using it, I still felt like my eyes had a lining of oily residue around them. Maybe it has changed in the past few years...
Gdeeaz Gdeeaz 7 years
I used to use that make up remover and it worked great for me. It even would get off our costume make up. The only reason I stopped using it was because I liked the pad removers better.
BallonDoggy BallonDoggy 7 years
The package does say Mascara remover, so maybe its not supposed to get off eyeliner? Don't know, don't use makeup remover either.
mcjx3 mcjx3 7 years
This is actually the makeup remover I use and it gets off my waterproof mascara pretty well. I've been using it for a couple years now.
Best Mascaras For Asian Lashes
Manny MUA's Dad Responds to Mean Tweet
Maybelline New York Studio Makeup Brushes
Louis C.K. With False Eyelashes | Saturday Night Live
From Our Partners
Latest Beauty
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds