PopSugar called it when she said that SMG looked feisty on Monday night at the Vaseline Skin Is Amazing event with her tightly pulled-back hair. Sarah Michelle has been getting a lot of props lately, especially when she stepped out in pretty plaits at the The Air I Breathe premiere. (I have a how-to coming up for you, straight from her stylist, so hold tight for that.)

This time around, I'm not so sure about Sarah's makeup. This dramatic eye paired with a chalky pale pink pout might be pretty for fashion runways, but I think it distracts from her natural beauty. Do you think this smouldering look works for SMG, or is it one of her rare missteps?