Colombani continued the experimental theme with the eye makeup, too. She mixed a red eye shadow (Love's Lure coming this Fall) with MAC Fast Response Eye Cream ($31) for a velvety texture along the center lid and lash line. The brows were styled straight without an arch for a more masculine effect. "Because we have no mascara, this gives structure to the face, which is important," she explained. And here's a tip on selecting the color of your next brow pencil: never go as dark as the hair. Go a tone or two lighter.