Skip Nav
Ulta Beauty
15 Incredible Beauty Products That Have Earned Their Ulta Beauty 5-Star Ratings
Gigi Hadid
Gigi Hadid's Cat Eye Will Make You Want to Buy White Eyeliner — Here Are Our 6 Favorites
Emilia Clarke
Emilia Clarke's Hair Is Now Targaryen Blond — Permanently!

Trend Alert: Heavy on the Liner

OK, pencils down, now who's got the right answer? In this case, it's thick black eyeliner. Each of these women used heavy hands for their black eyes at the CFDA Awards. There's a blurry difference between heavily lined and smoked up, so let's discuss. Kirsten Dunst has the most outlined look as her stroke — even the bottom! — traces the entire eye on the lash line. Ashley Olsen, on the other hand, has equally thick lines, but she blurs the edges into a cat-eye shape for a sultry rock look. Lastly, Heidi Klum falls somewhere in the middle with slight smudges on the bottom, but more definition up top. Whose look do you like best . . . or do you think it all got out of hand?

WireImage, Getty

Join The Conversation
mcollazo mcollazo 8 years
Love Ashley's need a tutorial.
lframe lframe 8 years
I love black eyeliner to glam it up. Ashely and Heidi seems to be my faves though.
LittleMzFit LittleMzFit 8 years
#1 Ashley! Runner Up: Heidi
Talldiva45 Talldiva45 8 years
Ashley and Heidi's look the best I think.
chiquita29 chiquita29 8 years
OMG Ashley looks gorgeous in this photo, I like her eyeliner best.
leslievanhouten leslievanhouten 8 years
mariserin- do a youtube search for guerlain eye kohl and there are a bunch of tutorials. HTH!
lizlee89 lizlee89 8 years
can you do a how-to on ashley's? I usually hate raccoon eyes, but I luv wing tips and I luv how hers is done. I always try and fail; help please...
AmberHoney AmberHoney 8 years
I think they all look like raccoons with blonde wigs on. :makeup:
AmandaG AmandaG 8 years
I do like the look. I learned at a photo shoot the most idiot proof way to get this look. She used a Maybaline Eye Brow pencil in black velvet sharpened to a very sharp point and then she softened it with a lighter to make it apply smoothly. After that she took a lipstick brush and set the liner with MAC black tied shadow. I tried it at home with no prob and went dancing in the Florida heat and it looked great all night! (FYI I can't even put on lipstick without several tries.
sparkleluvr sparkleluvr 8 years
I think they're all a bit too heavy handed, but I do love me some black eyeliner :-)
deeann deeann 8 years
i like ashley's it really emphasizes her beautiful eyes
Amanda-La Amanda-La 8 years
I like Kirstens.
mariserin mariserin 8 years
leslievanhoute--never heard of doing it like that but now i gotta try! doesn't it get in your eyes though?
Bebeshopper Bebeshopper 8 years
Isn't Heidi a little old for that look?
wasah wasah 8 years
anyone know how to get ashley's eyes?
any any 8 years
ashley and heidi's eyes look great!
emalove emalove 8 years
Never been a fan of heavy-looking liner.
mdemariah mdemariah 8 years
Ashley's! :D
LOVErickii LOVErickii 8 years
ashley :)
Jake Gyllenhaal and Kirsten Dunst Photos
Gigi Hadid's Style Icons
Tower of Terror Movie GIFs
Kirsten Dunst Shares Amazing Throwback Photos on Instagram
From Our Partners
Latest Beauty
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds