Back of Witchy Makeup Ideas: Sabrina, the Teenage Witch Over the past few days, I've been bringing you witchy makeup ideas, from Luna Lovegood to Elphaba to the White Witch. Now, let's get a bit nostalgic with Melissa Joan Hart's character from Sabrina, the Teenage Witch. To get this look, it's all about a mid-to-late-1990s feel, complete with a Rachel-style wig, a choker necklace with metallic accents, baubled bobby pins, and of course, some sparkling nail polish to mimic the dazzling effects of a magic wand. An oh-so-'90s brown-based lipstick and thin, yet emphasized, eyebrows finish off the look. For a whimsical touch, pay tribute to Sabrina's snarky cat Salem with some type of black cat accessory, whether it be a ring, an embellished compact, or a quirky evening bag. See more pictures of Sabrina here. View 5 Photos › Photo 1 Photo 2 Photo 3 Photo 4 Photo 5 Comments CorkinCokeACola 7 years I loved this show as a kid. Pistil 7 years Bella, your makeup ideas are just too pretty for Halloween! leslievanhouten 7 years 90s= MAC Spice w/ Twig!