There's a lot that beauty-lovers hope for from mascaras [1], but those dreams can be instantly ruined if the formula is too thick or goopy, looking more like tar on your lashes than makeup. If the idea of a single clump sends shivers down your spine, CoverGirl just created a new mascara you'll be thankful for.

The new CoverGirl Exhibitionist Uncensored Mascara [2] ($8) is a dream for lovers of natural-looking makeup [3]. It's formulated with coconut and jojoba oils, which means it hydrates your lashes while you're wearing it. When I first tried it, I was relieved to see that the spoolie wand coated every single one of my lashes in a dark black pigment. The formula is easy to build on, too — even with the multitude of layers I applied, it never looked clumped. In fact, the mascara just made it look like I was born with really dark, defined, envy-inducing eyelashes.

Another perk? It will not smear or flake. There's nothing worse to me than when a mascara starts flaking off, creating a flurry of black dots beneath my eyes. I spend quite a lot of time brightening up [4] that area, so it infuriates me when a mascara ruins it. Luckily this product stays put all day, allowing my eye makeup to look as good as when I first applied it.

While I might prefer a more dramatic mascara for the evening, this pick is ideal for workdays and weekends when I just want a little bit extra definition to my eyes, without looking like I have a lot of makeup on. Check out the mascara ahead.

CoverGirl Exhibitionist Uncensored Mascara

CoverGirl Exhibitionist Uncensored Mascara [5] ($8)