Skip Nav
Award Season
58 Emmys Moments That You Definitely Didn't See on TV
Game of Thrones
Kit Harington and Emilia Clarke Are Just as Cute Together in Real Life
Mandy Moore
9 Guys Mandy Moore Has Let Into Her Wild Heart (Excluding Jack Pearson)

American Idol Top 12

American Idol Top 12 — Beatles Night

Last night kicked off the Top 12 men and women performing together and they sang Beatles songs! Too bad a lot of them butchered the beautiful tunes. My favorites this week were Brooke, David Cook and top spot goes to Chikezie. Since they all have been faves of mine since early on I won't bore you with rave reviews.

Carly was also entertaining and Jason, Michael and Syesha were good as well. As for the stinkers, Kristy Lee looked smoking hot but that country song on speed was beyond terrible. David Hernandez sounded and looked cheesy and like Simon said, "desperate." Amanda still bugs (sorry all you fans) and Ramiele was a disappointing blah. David Archuleta hasn't had a bad night yet but forgetting the lyrics should be an automatic elimination at this point. Bottom line, the bottom three will be David Hernandez, Kristy Lee Cook and probably Syesha but my bet is David's getting the boot. Check out Buzz for more from last night's American Idol and don't forget to vote on who you think is going to be sent home tonight.

Photo courtesy of Fox

Join The Conversation
hmweis1 hmweis1 9 years
I thought Jason was awesome. I absolutely love his voice. I think in the end it should be Carly, Jason, and David Cook. I have a feeling David A is in it for the long run, because of all the teenage girls.
orisugar orisugar 9 years
Pop, did you mean David Archeletta or David Hernandez? I think David Hernandez will go after Kristy Lee
milosmommy milosmommy 9 years
I'm sorry but I would much rather hear forgotten lyrics than that horrendous butchering that Kristy did to that song. It was just murder to my ears. I hope she goes.
CJaneTyp CJaneTyp 9 years
David Cook has really come on for me. I thought he was a cheez ball at first but now he's really upped his game. I LOVED him last night. Also LOVED Chikezie for the first time. Carly is always great and killed it last night. I also really love the guy with the dreads whose name I never remember... Jason? I would actually buy his stuff. Archuletta missed the boat last night. Syesha comes off as really full of herself and bugs me. Ramiele is totally forgettable. Hernandez is a cheesy joke- why didn't he just say in his intro that he used to be a stripper last year? haha. Pizza Parlor. Puhleeez. Country girl will stay because there are a lot of country fans. Sayonara to Hernandez.
PrincessPeach87 PrincessPeach87 9 years
I dislike American takes my precious house away and it's such a low brow show....errr
s0Jones6 s0Jones6 9 years
I love, love, love Carly Smithson! She is consistently amazing! Go Ireland!
xrawk_starrx xrawk_starrx 9 years
Kristy Lee was TERRIBLE! David Cook was awesome! I love him. And David Archuleta BUTCHERED his song!
acemonkey acemonkey 9 years
Bye Kristy Lee! She needs to go for butchering both Journey and the Beattles!
AshleyDaigh AshleyDaigh 9 years
I can't stand AIdol
inlovewithhim inlovewithhim 9 years
Kristy Lee needs a stylist.. BAD! She could probably make it in country music (girl won't touch Carrie Underwood status) shes really rough around the edges.
Liss1 Liss1 9 years
I just can't get into AI this season. I used to watch it faithfully every week but i just can't seem to now. I watched 3 performances last night and i thought David Cook did a great job!
i-am-awesomeness i-am-awesomeness 9 years
I agree. I'm really sick of this show! I don't even watch it, but I'm tired of hearing the news all the time.
DreaAST DreaAST 9 years
I'm so sick of this show!
Briandiesel Briandiesel 9 years
It really hurt my feelings that Kristy Lee got to get up there and "sing" that shiteous version of a classic and Kady Malloy was sitting at home. Bye Bye Kristy! (crossing fingers) I felt so bad for Muffaletta, I was sure he was gonna cry, but nope, he just kept smiling and giggling. I love him!
chellybean chellybean 9 years
Kristy must go home immediately. That was the worst thing I had ever heard!
lizzylu49 lizzylu49 9 years
Bottom three will be Kristy, Ramiele and Syesha (with Syesha going home).
When Is American Idol Coming Back?
From Our Partners
Latest Celebrity & Entertainment
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds