Ashley Benson may have caused a stir with her first Halloween [1] look — she dressed up as Cecil the Lion [2] and asked her Instagram followers what they thought before editing the post and later apologizing — but her latest costume is sure to be a little less controversial. She and her rumored boyfriend, Tyler Blackburn [3], donned creepy makeup and called themselves vampires for a Friday-night Halloween event. Ashley's look even included a fang mark on her chest. Check out Ashley's less-offensive getup, and then see what all the other stars are wearing for Halloween this year [4]!