Ben Higgins and Lauren Bushnell seemed to have a picture-perfect romance, but like most relationships that start on The Bachelor [1], it didn't last. After getting engaged during season 20 and starring on their own spinoff show [2], Ben and Lauren: Happily Ever After?, the couple eventually parted ways in May 2017 [3]. Following Ben's emotional appearance on The Bachelor Winter Games [4] this season, we can't help but reminisce about what used to be. Look back at the former pair's happier moments together below.